Abstract:Logical frameworks based on intuitionistic or linear logics with higher-type quantification have been successfully used to give high-level, modular, and formal specifications of many important judgments in the area of programming languages and inference systems. Given such specifications, it is natural to consider proving properties about the specified systems in the framework: for example, given the specification of evaluation for a functional programming language, prove that the language is deterministic or that evaluation preserves types. One challenge in developing a framework for such reasoning is that higher-order abstract syntax (HOAS), an elegant and declarative treatment of object-level abstraction and substitution, is difficult to treat in proofs involving induction. In this paper, we present a meta-logic that can be used to reason about judgments coded using HOAS; this meta-logic is an extension of a simple intuitionistic logic that admits higher-order quantification over simply typed lambda-terms (key ingredients for HOAS) as well as induction and a notion of definition. We explore the difficulties of formal meta-theoretic analysis of HOAS encodings by considering encodings of intuitionistic and linear logics, and formally derive the admissibility of cut for important subsets of these logics. We then propose an approach to avoid the apparent tradeoff between the benefits of higher-order abstract syntax and the ability to analyze the resulting encodings. We illustrate this approach through examples involving the simple functional and imperative programming languages PCF and PCF:=. We formally derive such properties as unicity of typing, subject reduction, determinacy of evaluation, and the equivalence of transition semantics and natural semantics presentations of evaluation.

Hybrid Type-Logical Grammars, First-Order Linear Logic and the Descriptive Inadequacy of Lambda Grammars

Hybrid: A Definitional Two-Level Approach to Reasoning with Higher-Order Abstract Syntax

Algebraic semantics for hybrid logics

Classical linear logic, cobordisms and categorial grammars

Reasoning with Higher-Order Abstract Syntax in a Logical Framework

Classical linear logic, cobordisms and categorical semantics of categorial grammars

Definite Descriptions and Hybrid Tense Logic

Synchronous Games, Simulations and lambda-calculus

From Double Pushout Grammars to Hypergraph Lambek Grammars With and Without Exponential Modality

Syllogisms in Rudimentary Linear Logic, Diagrammatically

Linguistic Grammar As Dynamic Logic

A Mixed Linear and Graded Logic: Proofs, Terms, and Models (with appendices)

Complete Dynamic Logic of Communicating Hybrid Programs

A Two-Dimensional Hybrid Logic Of Subset Spaces

The Grail theorem prover: Type theory for syntax and semantics

Completeness of tableau calculi for two-dimensional hybrid logics

Deciding Regular Grammar Logics with Converse Through First-Order Logic

A Complete V-Equational System for Graded lambda-Calculus

Parallel and algebraic lambda-calculi in intuitionistic propositional logic

Axioms for the Theory of Lambda-Conversion

Implicit automata in λ-calculi III: affine planar string-to-string functions