The barriers and enablers to providing healthy food in New Zealand secondary school canteens

O. Coady,C. Smith,S. Styles

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0029665124000430

2024-05-09

Proceedings of The Nutrition Society

Abstract:Establishing healthy lifelong eating habits in young people is important for short and long-term health (1) . Schools are ideal setting to improve diet. However, research shows that many school food environments are unhealthy (2) . In New Zealand (NZ), the canteen is a popular food provision, particularly in secondary schools. This research aimed to explore the barriers and enablers to providing healthy food and beverages in NZ secondary school canteens. In 2022, 6 secondary schools were purposively selected to participate in semi-structured interviews about foods and beverages sold in schools' canteens and the factors that influenced this. In total, 11 stakeholders representing six schools and one staff member of an external catering company completed interviews. The interviews were transcribed and analysed using a reflexive thematic analysis approach (3) . Four themes were developed. Theme 1 Action-oriented school policies that are based on healthy eating principles can facilitate healthier canteens highlighted the use and characteristics of policies. The subtheme highlighted that Mandatory policies are more enforceable. Theme 2 Multiple component opt-in programs or interventions facilitate a healthier school food provision shows that opt-in government interventions (e.g. Ka Ora, Ka Ako, the NZ free school lunch initiative) with funding, monitoring, and incentives can improve food provision. The subtheme Health-enhancing changes inthe school environment has flow-on effect to canteens showed that these changes can affect the entire school food environment. Theme 3 Healthy canteens get lost in the "pecking order" of what's important highlights that while schools and key stakeholders may believe healthy eating is important, other factors related to well-being and education were more important to prioritise within the school's limited resources. Theme 4 People's values, attitudes and beliefs may help and hinder the healthiness of canteens and explores the role champions have in influencing the healthiness of the canteen. Champions were those with a positive, proactive attitude, value healthy eating and are capable. Subtheme 1 Meet student preferences while providing healthy food was a common barrier many champions worked hard to overcome. The final subtheme identified how A collaborative approach within schools and their communities can overcome barriers to healthy canteens. Government mandates and interventions can positively impact the canteen and other food provisions. This research supports a recommendation for schools to create and implement school policies around food encompassing a whole-school approach.

nutrition & dietetics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the barriers and facilitators to providing healthy food in secondary school canteens in New Zealand. The research background emphasizes that fostering healthy eating habits among adolescents in the school environment is crucial for their short-term and long-term health. However, the current food environment in many schools is not conducive to healthy eating. In New Zealand, secondary school canteens are one of the main places where students obtain food.

The study collected data through semi-structured interviews with stakeholders from six secondary schools and employees of an external catering company. The interviews focused on the types of food and beverages sold in school canteens and the factors influencing them, and the data was processed using reflexive thematic analysis. The study identified four main themes:

1. **Action-oriented school policies**: Policies based on healthy eating principles help achieve a healthier canteen environment. It was particularly noted that mandatory policies are easier to enforce.

2. **Multi-faceted opt-in programs or interventions**: Government-initiated opt-in programs (such as the free school lunch program) can improve the food supply situation in schools through funding support, supervision mechanisms, and incentives. These changes may also have a positive impact on the overall food environment of the school.

3. **Priority of healthy canteens**: Although schools and stakeholders generally consider healthy eating important, they often prioritize matters directly related to well-being and education in the context of limited resources.

4. **People's perceptions, attitudes, and beliefs**: Proactive attitudes and recognition of the value of healthy eating can promote the provision of healthier food in canteens to some extent. The study mentioned the role of "health advocates," who play a crucial role in reconciling the conflict between student preferences and the provision of healthy food. Additionally, collaborative approaches between schools and communities can help overcome barriers to providing healthy food.

In summary, both directive and supportive government policies, as well as cooperation at the school and community levels, can positively impact the food environment in secondary school canteens. Therefore, the study recommends that schools should create and implement comprehensive food safety and nutrition policies.