Abstract:1. Studies at local to national extent have documented a recovery in macroinvertebrate taxonomic richness following improvements in water quality. The study by Haase et al. (2023) published in Nature claimed that the overall recovery came to a halt across Europe by 2010. However, the lack of monitoring design, the varying lengths in time series and heterogeneous taxonomic resolution (species, genus and families), along with insufficient information on data handling prior to statistical analyses are raising questions about the reliability of the findings. 2. Here I use the open access raw data of the original study to calculate the proportion of taxa identified to the targeted taxonomic resolution (species, genus or family), which revealed a lack of taxonomic consistency within some of the time-series. I then devised a simple taxonomic correction to remove potential biases in the richness trend estimates through the modelling procedures using linear models. 3. In order to make the data more comparable across studies and over time, I calculated an anomaly in taxonomic richness relative to a five-year reference period within 1990-2020, so all time series (greater than or equal to 15 years long, greater than or equal to 8 samples) overlapped. The concept is borrowed from the familiar temperature anomaly in climate research to track deviations from a norm. I ran non-linear trend analyses to reveal changes in the anomaly in taxonomic richness during the period 1990-2020. 4. European taxonomic richness using 1816 sites in 47 studies (full dataset) increased linearly by about 0.29 +/- 0.09 taxa per year when using all taxonomic ranks (species, genus, family), compared to the average 0.20 taxa per year in the original study, but dropped to 0.15 +/- 0.04 taxa per year at family level. The same results were produced after geographical thinning to 687 sites separated by at least 20 km from each other's. Further data analyses revealed the extent of discrepancies in taxonomic resolution (proportion of taxa identified to species or genus level) within time-series and its impact on trend estimates. 5. The linear increase in abundance over time was marginal (1 individual / year or 0.12% of average abundance) in the full dataset and not significant within 1990-2020 period, contrary to published findings (1.17%) due to a calculation error in the original study. 6. The linear analyses of species richness were run on centred years and did not allow the study of the temporal dynamics in taxonomic richness. Non-linear analyses using the anomaly in taxonomic richness for the period 1990-2020 revealed no change in taxonomic richness apart from a post millennium small and short rise using all taxonomic ranks (1120 sites, 27 studies), possibly due to a concurrent increase in sampling effort (abundance) across sites. 7. Coarsening the taxonomic resolution to family level did not alter the dynamic of the anomaly in taxonomic richness over time, possibly a result from poor sample sampling effort. The average 'species' richness (762 sites) was about 30 taxa per sample, barely higher than family richness (20 taxa per sample) and very small compared to studies with more intensive sampling efforts. Independently of the effect of anthropogenic impacts, I question the adequacy of the current biomonitoring design and sample sampling effort to study river macroinvertebrate biodiversity. 8. Implications of new findings. Linear trend estimates in taxonomic richness (independently of the time period) were dependent on taxonomic resolution, higher at 'species' than family level. Neither the abundance nor the anomaly in taxonomic richness showed signs of recovery during the period 1990-2020. Current sampling efforts for rapid bioindicators, such as those developed for the European Water Framework Directive, are inadequate to address the needs of the EU 2030 Biodiversity Strategy. Macroinvertebrates would be right to demand more from us.

Species specific responses to stressors hamper Trichoptera recovery

Four decades of region- and species-specific trends in lowland stream Ephemeroptera abundance

Water quality deterioration remains a major stressor for macroinvertebrate, diatom and fish communities in German rivers

Global-scale quantification of responses to anthropogenic stressors in six riverine organism groups

Drivers of recovery and degradation of riverine benthic macroinvertebrate communities: A nationwide analysis of time series

Alterations to water quality and quantity elicit similar stream fish functional trait responses in three North American rivers

Stream macroinvertebrate communities in restored and impacted catchments respond differently to climate, land-use, and runoff over a decade

Freshwater fish in mid and northern German rivers – Long-term trends and associated species traits

Ecological but Not Biological Traits of European Riverine Invertebrates Respond Consistently to Anthropogenic Impacts

Trout and invertebrate assemblages in stream pools through wildfire and drought

The recovery of European freshwater biodiversity has come to a halt

European freshwater macroinvertebrate richness and abundance: alternative analyses and new findings

How tolerances, competition and dispersal shape benthic invertebrate colonisation in restored urban streams

Pervasive decline of subtropical aquatic insects over 20 years driven by water transparency, non-native fish and stoichiometric imbalance

Continuous riverine biodiversity changes in a 10‐years‐post‐restoration‐study—Impacts and pitfalls

Alien Species and Climate Change Drive Shifts in a Riverine Fish Community and Trait Compositions over 35 Years.

Linking wastewater treatment plant effluents to water quality and hydrology: Effects of multiple stressors on fish communities

The accumulation of anthropogenic stressors induces a progressive shift in the ecological preferences and morphological traits shared by riparian plant communities

A synthesis of anthropogenic stress effects on emergence-mediated aquatic-terrestrial linkages and riparian food webs

Functional traits reveal the dominant drivers of long‐term community change across a North American Great Lake

Wastewater and warming effects on aquatic invertebrates: Experimental insights into multi-level biodiversity consequences