Effectiveness of exercise-based sports injury prevention programmes in reducing injury rates in adolescents and their implementation in the community: a mixed-methods systematic review

Zhe Xin Zhang,Joseph Lai,Liang Shen,Lingaraj Krishna
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2023-107717
IF: 18.4793
2024-06-01
British Journal of Sports Medicine
Abstract:Objective Despite evidence supporting the efficacy of sport injury prevention programmes (SIPPs) in adolescents, implementation of SIPPs in community settings is low. This review aims to synthesise and integrate evidence on the efficacy of exercise-based SIPPs in reducing injury rates in adolescents with implementation strategies for such programmes in the community. Design A systematic review with meta-analysis, narrative synthesis and meta-aggregation was conducted, followed by a convergent segregated approach to integrate the findings. Sensitivity and subgroup analyses were conducted. Study appraisal was performed using Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal Checklists and Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool. Data sources Literature search of nine databases was carried out to identify studies in English from January 2012 to December 2022. Eligibility criteria Included were randomised controlled trials (RCTs), qualitative or mixed-methods studies. Population included adolescents (10–19 years). Interventions included SIPPs. Outcomes were injury rate and rate ratio (IRR). Phenomena of interest were facilitators and barriers to the implementation of SIPPs. Results 23 studies were included for analysis. Meta-analysis for 16 RCTs showed a protective effect of SIPP (IRR 0.63, 95% CI 0.53 to 0.74, p<0.00001) in adolescents. Meta-aggregation of seven qualitative/mixed-method studies revealed four sets of synthesised findings that impact implementation namely players' perceptions and beliefs, coaches as key facilitators, organisational support and characteristics of the SIPP. Conclusion Implementation of SIPPs provides a 37% risk reduction in adolescents but requires targeting key stakeholders through a top-down multifaceted approach for its efficacy to be translated. Future research should investigate the effectiveness of SIPPs and implementation strategies in adolescents in community settings.
sport sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the implementation effect of sports injury prevention programs for adolescents (SIPPs) in the community environment and its influencing factors. Specifically, the research aims to synthesize and integrate the evidence regarding the effectiveness of exercise - based SIPPs in reducing the injury rate among adolescents, and explore the implementation strategies of these programs in the community. Through systematic review and mixed - methods analysis, the study hopes to answer the following two main questions: 1. How effective are exercise - based SIPPs in reducing the injury rate among adolescents in the community environment? 2. What are the facilitating factors and barriers that affect the implementation of SIPPs in the community environment? ### Research Background In recent years, the frequency and intensity of adolescents' participation in sports activities have increased significantly, which has led to an increase in the sports injury rate among adolescents. Although previous studies have shown that SIPPs have a significant effect in reducing sports injuries among adolescents, the practical application of these programs in the community environment is still limited. Therefore, understanding the implementation of SIPPs in the community and its influencing factors is crucial for improving their practical effects. ### Research Objectives 1. **Update and Synthesize Evidence**: Update and synthesize the evidence regarding the effectiveness of exercise - based SIPPs in reducing the injury rate among adolescents. 2. **Integrate Implementation Context**: Combine the evidence of effectiveness with the research on the implementation context to promote the transformation of evidence and improve the implementation effect. ### Main Findings - **Quantitative Analysis**: Through a meta - analysis of 16 randomized controlled trials (RCTs), the results showed that SIPPs have a significant protective effect among adolescents (IRR 0.63, 95% CI 0.53 to 0.74, p < 0.00001), that is, SIPPs can reduce the risk of sports injuries by 37%. - **Qualitative Analysis**: Through a meta - aggregative analysis of 7 qualitative or mixed - methods studies, four main factors affecting the implementation of SIPPs were found: - **Athletes' Perceptions and Beliefs**: Athletes' perceptions and beliefs about SIPPs will affect their motivation to adopt these programs. - **Role of Coaches/Teachers**: Coaches and teachers are the main implementers of SIPPs, and their attitudes and support are crucial for the successful implementation of SIPPs. - **Organizational Support**: The commitment and support of the organization are the keys to the successful implementation of SIPPs, including providing training resources and publicity and promotion. - **Characteristics of SIPPs**: The adaptability and ease of use of SIPPs will also affect their adoption and use in the community. ### Conclusion SIPPs have a significant effect on reducing sports injuries among adolescents, but in order to transform their effects into actual public health impacts, a top - down multi - level approach is required to promote implementation, especially focusing on the participation of key stakeholders (such as organizations, coaches, and athletes). Future research should further explore the effectiveness and implementation strategies of SIPPs in the community environment.