Towards the Implementation of a Value Framework for Diagnostic Technologies: Operationalization, Piloting and Validation in Latin America.

Federico Augustovski,Fernando Argento,Andrea Alcaraz,Sebastián García Martí,Andrés Pichon Riviere,Verónica Alfie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jval.2023.09.3001
IF: 5.156
2024-02-01
Value in Health
Abstract:OBJECTIVE: In 2020, a group of 30 stakeholders from Latin America established fifteen criteria for a value framework (D-VF) to assess and make decisions on diagnostic technologies. This paper aims to present the operationalization, piloting, and initial validation of the framework for its implementation.METHODS: This work was carried out collaboratively with a variety of stakeholders. Three sequential phases were undertaken: (1) operationalization of the D-VF through a literature search for conceptual definitions and assessment tools; (2) piloting of the D-VF through a rapid health technology assessment (HTA) document applying the methodology of the framework; and, (3) a face validation process conducted through a virtual workshop. Usefulness and implementation of the framework opinions were collected.RESULTS: The operationalization of the framework was conducted, and a methodological user guide was published. The D-VF criteria were applied in an HTA document on HPV testing in cervical cancer screening. Also, an open-access training program was developed. Stakeholders agreed on the usefulness of the D-VF for assessment and decision-making stages of diagnostic technologies. However, they highlighted the need to improve technical capacities and the potential for added complexity when applying a D-VF with many criteria. The absence of an established value framework for diagnostic technologies in LA and the potential for strengthening technical capacities made the project valuable to those involved.CONCLUSIONS: The framework was shown to be fit for implementation in real-life decision-making settings after the operationalization, piloting, and initial validation phases. Further experiences are needed to support its implementation.
health care sciences & services,health policy & services,economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?