Abstract:An important policy question in China is how to equitably allocate the responsibility for reducing carbon emissions. China has already introduced provincial targets to achieve a national carbon intensity reduction of 17% in its Twelfth Five-Year Plan, and the design of a cap-and-trade system is currently under discussion. Using a computable general equilibrium model with energy system detail, we assess alternative criteria--production emissions, consumption emissions, and a shared production and consumption metric--for allocating the national CO2 intensity target across provinces, and compare them to the existing politically-negotiated targets. We show how economic cost can be lowered and equity goals addressed by employing a permit trading mechanism and how equity goals can be achieved through the choice of index used to determine the initial allocation. We find that adjusting the provincial targets on a consumption basis increases the emissions-reduction burden for the eastern provinces by about 60%, while alleviating the burden for the central and western provinces by about 50% each. This adjustment makes meeting policy targets more expensive--the CGE analysis indicates that this adjustment could double China's national welfare loss compared to the homogenous and politically-based distribution of reduction targets. The welfare losses for the eastern provinces increase by a factor of four, while providing little relief for the central and western provinces. A shared-responsibility approach that balances production-based and consumption-based emissions responsibilities alleviates those unbalancing effects and lead to a more equal distribution of economic burden among China's provinces. An emissions-trading system (ETS) that achieves the same reduction and applies various criteria to determine the initial allocation lowers the cost relative to all corresponding intensity target scenarios while still addressing equity concerns.

Path analysis for carbon transfers embodied in China's international trade and policy implications for mitigation targets

Mapping global carbon footprint in China

Transfers of air pollutant emissions embodied in China's foreign trade based on MRIO model

Spatial characteristics analysis of sectoral carbon transfer path in international trade: A comparison of the United States and China

Estimation of China's Embodied CO2 Emissions During 2000–2009

Drivers of carbon emission transfer in China-An analysis of international trade from 2004 to 2011

CO2 Embodied in China's Foreign Trade 2007 with Discussion for Global Climate Policy

Identifying the critical paths and sectors for carbon transfers driven by global consumption in 2015

The Influence of International Trade to China's Embodied Carbon Emissions During 2000-2009:Based on Consumption and SRIO Model

Characteristics and transfer paths of CO2 emissions embodied in trade and China's carbon reduction strategies

A comprehensive study on carbon emissions flows and key drivers within China's domestic and global value chains

CO2 Emissions Embodied in China's Trade and Reduction Policy Assessment

Transfer Characteristics of Embodied Carbon Emissions in Export Trade—Evidence from China

Analysis of CO2 Emissions Embodied in China's Bilateral Trade: a Non-Competitive Import Input–output Approach

Quantitative Estimation of the Climatic Effects of Carbon Transferred by International Trade

Incorporating Consumption-Based Emissions Accounting into Climate Policy in China: Provincial Target Setting and ETS Baseline Allocations

Carbon emissions embodied in the global supply chain: Intermediate and final trade imbalances

Inter-provincial sectoral embodied CO2 net-transfer analysis in China based on hypothetical extraction method and complex network analysis

Empirical estimation and analysis of total carbon emission quota based on carbon transfer–embedded import and export trade

Pathways to achieve low-carbon transition in the transportation sector under the constraints of carbon peak and carbon neutrality targets: A comprehensive analysis of intra- and extra-industry factors

Weighing China's embodied CO2 emissions and value added under global value chains: Trends, characteristics, and paths