Abstract:Analysis of strong gravitational lensing data is important in this era of precision cosmology. The objective of the present study is to directly compare the analysis of strong gravitational lens systems using different lens model software and similarly parameterized models to understand the differences and limitations of the resulting models. The software lens model translation tool, HydraLens, was used to generate multiple models for four strong lens systems including COSMOS J095930+023427, SDSS J1320+1644, SDSSJ1430+4105 and J1000+0021. All four lens systems were modeled with PixeLens, Lenstool, glafic, and Lensmodel. The input data and parameterization of each lens model was similar for the four model programs used to highlight differences in the output results. The calculation of the Einstein radius and enclosed mass for each lens model was comparable. The results were more dissimilar if the masses of more than one lens potential were free-parameters. The image tracing algorithms of the software are different, resulting in different output image positions and differences in time delay and magnification calculations, as well as ellipticity and position angle of the resulting lens model. In a comparison of different software versions using identical model input files, results differed significantly when using two versions of the same software. These results further support the need for future lensing studies to include multiple lens models, use of open software, availability of lens model files use in studies, and computer challenges to develop new approaches. Future studies need a standard nomenclature and specification of the software used to allow improved interpretation, reproducibility and transparency of results.

A comparison of approximate gravitational lens equations and a proposal for an improved new one

Correspondence between two gravitational lens equations in a static and spherically symmetric spacetime

Gravitational Lensing Analysed by the Graded Refractive Index of A Vacuum

An accurate equation for the gravitational bending of light by a static massive object

A Simple Optical Analysis of Gravitational Lensing

Spacetime perspective of Schwarzschild lensing

Lensing of gravitational waves: efficient wave-optics methods and validation with symmetric lenses

Asymptotic expansions and amplification of a gravitational lens near a fold caustic

Gravitational lensing in metric theories of gravity

Toward Gravitational Lensing in Modified Theories of Gravity

Geometric optics approximation for the Einstein vacuum equations

Investigating strong gravitational lensing with black hole metrics modified with an additional term

Erratum To: Strong Gravitational Lensing in the Einstein-Proca Theory

Numerical wave optics and the lensing of gravitational waves by globular clusters

Statistics Of Gravitational Lenses - The Uncertainties

The Gravitational Lens Equation for Embedded Lenses: Magnification and Ellipticity

Comparison of Strong Gravitational Lens Model Software III. Direct and indirect semi-independent lens model comparisons of COSMOS J095930+023427, SDSS J1320+1644, SDSSJ1430+4105 and J1000+0021

The cosmological lens equation and the equivalent single-plane gravitational lens

Equivalence between definitions of the gravitational deflection angle of light for a stationary spacetime

Gravitational lens effect of a holonomy corrected Schwarzschild black hole

Testing an exact diffraction formula with gravitational wave source lensed by a supermassive black hole in binary systems