Species occurrences of Mio-Pliocene horses (Equidae) from Florida: sampling, ecology, or both?

Stephanie R. Killingsworth,Bruce J. MacFadden

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/pab.2023.35

2024-01-25

Paleobiology

Abstract:During the late Miocene and early Pliocene (latest Hemphillian, Hh4 interval, 5.7 to 4.75 Ma) a distinctive suite of four species of extinct horses (Family Equidae) were widespread in North America. This includes Nannippus aztecus, Neohipparion eurystyle, Astrohippus stocki, and Dinohippus mexicanus. In Florida, two additional equid species, Pseudhipparion simpsoni and Cormohipparion emsliei, are also typically found at Hh4 localities. Here we compare horses from four Hh4 Florida fossil sites, including three from the Bone Valley mines and a fourth from the recently discovered Montbrook site. Two of these sites have all six expected species, one has five species, and one has only four species present. To explain these differences, we used species counts from research databases and rarefaction simulation to clarify the relative abundances, species richness, and occurrences of these horses from these four sites. The Palmetto Mine (Agrico) site, with five equid species, appears to lack the sixth species owing to ecological reasons. This is different from Montbrook, the site with only four of the six species. Results indicate that Montbrook is likely lacking two missing equid species for a couple of reasons: sampling bias and biological/ecological causes. Our results demonstrate that sampling biases can account for observed equid species richness when the overall abundance of certain equid species is low. Nevertheless, other factors, including ecology and with sufficient resolution, perhaps also time, may also explain the distribution and occurrences of individual species at these and other fossil sites. In a broader perspective, analyses such as this example provide an opportunity to address a persistent challenge in paleontology, that is, how do we explain absences of extinct taxa from the fossil record?

paleontology,evolutionary biology,ecology,biodiversity conservation

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of the numerical differences in the appearance of several extinct Equidae species at different fossil sites in Florida during the late Miocene to early Pliocene (approximately 5.7 to 4.75 million years ago). Specifically, the study compares four fossil sites, including three from the Bone Valley mining district and one recently discovered Montbrook site. Among these four sites, two sites found six predicted Equidae species, one site found five, while Montbrook found only four.

To explain these differences, researchers utilized species occurrence data from the study database to better understand the relative abundance, species richness, and occurrence of these Equidae species at each site. The results indicate that the absence of two Equidae species at Montbrook may be due to sampling bias and biological/ecological reasons. Additionally, the study emphasizes the importance of sampling bias in explaining species occurrences in the fossil record and suggests that other factors such as ecology may also influence the distribution and occurrence of species at fossil sites. Through this analysis, the research provides an opportunity to address a persistent challenge in paleontology: how to interpret the absence of extinct species in the fossil record.