Control Strategies and Stabilization Techniques for DC/DC Converters Application in DC MGs: Challenges, Opportunities, and Prospects—A Review

Aphrodis Nduwamungu,Tek Tjing Lie,Ioannis Lestas,Nirmal-Kumar C. Nair,Kosala Gunawardane
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17030669
IF: 3.2
2024-02-01
Energies
Abstract:DC microgrids (DC MGs) offer advantages such as efficiency, control, cost, reliability, and size compared to AC MGs. However, they often operate with numerous constant power loads (CPLs), exhibiting a negative incremental impedance characteristic that can lead to instability. This instability weakens stability boundaries and reduces system damping, especially when dealing with pulsed power loads (PPLs) on electric aircraft, ships, and cars. Linear controllers may not ensure stability across various operations, causing voltage dips and potential system instability. To secure DC/DC converter functionality and comply with impedance specifications, it is crucial to consider minor loop gain in control strategies and stabilization techniques. Employing diverse methods to decrease minor loop gain in DC/DC converters is essential. A comprehensive evaluation, including strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats (SWOT) analysis, is conducted to assess control strategies, stabilization techniques, and stability standards for different DC/DC converters, identifying SWOT.
energy & fuels
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper primarily reviews the control and stability issues faced by DC-DC converters in DC microgrids (DC MGs). The core aim of the paper is to evaluate existing control strategies and stabilization techniques, and to explore the effectiveness of these methods in addressing the challenges posed by constant power loads (CPLs) and pulsed power loads (PPLs) in DC microgrids. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following key points: 1. **Problems caused by Constant Power Loads (CPLs)**: CPLs have negative incremental impedance characteristics, which can weaken the system stability margin and reduce system damping, especially when dealing with pulsed power loads. Traditional linear controllers may not ensure system stability across the entire operating range, leading to voltage drops and potential system instability. 2. **Problems caused by Pulsed Power Loads (PPLs)**: PPLs consume a large amount of energy in a short period, which can drive the microgrid away from its steady-state operating point, resulting in significant voltage drops and system instability. Traditional linear control methods cannot guarantee system stability over a wider operating range. 3. **Control Strategies and Stabilization Techniques**: The paper explores various control strategies and stabilization techniques, including virtual capacitance, virtual impedance, pole placement techniques, and loop cancellation methods, to stabilize DC-DC converters supplying power to CPLs and PPLs. Additionally, advanced control techniques such as predictive control, backstepping control, and sliding mode control are discussed for their potential to improve system dynamic response and reliability. 4. **Control Architecture of DC Microgrids**: The paper also discusses the importance of control architecture in DC microgrids, particularly how hierarchical control architecture can enhance the flexibility and efficiency of microgrids through multi-level control. Hierarchical control typically includes primary control, secondary control, and tertiary control. 5. **Future Trends and Recommendations**: Finally, the paper presents an outlook on future research directions, emphasizing areas that need further development, such as improving control strategies to address negative incremental impedance and power imbalance issues, and developing new grid standards to accommodate converter-based grids. In summary, this paper aims to comprehensively review and evaluate the control strategies and stabilization techniques for DC-DC converters in DC microgrids, while identifying the advantages, disadvantages, challenges, and limitations of these technologies, and proposing future research directions.