Edouard Challe discussion of: Consequences of weak monetary policy

Edouard Challe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/epolic/eiad037

2024-02-29

Economic Policy

Abstract:Macroeconomists face a severe shortage of large-scale monetary policy experiments they can use to test their theories. In rich countries like the United States or Euro Area countries, only two such experiments have occurred over the last several decades: the conversion to inflation targeting in the 1980s, initiated by the 'Volcker shock' of 1979 in the United States, and the adoption of unconventional policies – most notably Forward Guidance and Quantitative Easing – in the aftermath of the Great Financial Crisis. The New Keynesian model, the mainstream framework of analysis for short-run fluctuations and stabilization policies, has been extensively confronted with those events, with mixed success. For example, the experience of Forward Guidance has revealed its vulnerability to the 'Forward Guidance Puzzle', which appears well and alive a decade after its discovery despite a broad assault by the profession. In contrast, the transition to inflation targeting has been more lenient to the theory. The textbook explanation for the switch from monetary and macroeconomic instability in the 1970s to stability from the mid-1980s onwards, in the United States and elsewhere, is that the Taylor principle was not satisfied before the 1980s, opening the door to self-fulfilling fluctuations in aggregate demand, output and inflation. Generations of graduate students have been taught to think of the transition from the Great Inflation of the 1970s to the Great Moderation starting in the mid-1980s through the lens of the New Keynesian model with a changing Taylor rule parameter.

economics