Abstract:Animals adjust behavior to changes in perceived predation risk, their so called landscape of fear. However, individuals within populations can differ greatly in their plasticity towards perceived risk. In national parks, where animals are often protected from human hunting, wildlife may start losing their fear of humans and become more observable, a process that starts at the individual level. Here we aim to test whether ungulates in one of the only largely non-hunted populations in Europe show individual variation in behavioral plasticity towards gradients of human disturbance. We used random regression to dissolve the individual movement responses of 63 red deer (Cervus elaphus) to spatio-temporal variation in human recreation. We measured human disturbance as the number of recreationists on the closest trail on a given day. We quantified conditional repeatability, i.e., between-individual variation, along the perceived risk gradient. To avoid pseudoreplication, we fitted models to the hours of the day with peak activity or passivity. Diel activity patterns were conserved across individuals in our population, with peak activity in the early morning and late evening. When actively foraging during the morning, red deer responded to human disturbance with flight, i.e., longer hourly movement distances, while they reduced movement in response to disturbance when resting in the middle of the day. Between-individual variation increased with visitor frequentation, i.e., red deer behaved similarly when human disturbance was low, but with increasing human disturbance some deer adjusted movement while others responded little. Our results show that individuals varied greatly in their responsiveness towards human disturbance, with some resuming normal movement behavior. Flight responses are costly and may be selected against in non-hunted populations, leading to an increase in human-tolerant individuals over time. These are good news for national parks for which wildlife viewing is an effective tool to engage the public in conservation. Observing wildlife in Europe is difficult, likely due to a long persecution history and strong hunting pressure. Our results demonstrate that large non-hunting zones may, over time, successfully reduce wildlifes extreme fear of humans.

Valuing wildlife sightings at the species-wide and individual animal levels: an approach and application to bear viewing in Yellowstone National Park

The Nature of the Beast: Wildlife Valuation from the Iconic to the Ordinary

Quantifying impacts of recreation on elk (Cervus canadensis) using novel modeling approaches

Welfare and Distribution in State-Led Wildlife Management

Leveraging big data for outdoor recreation management: A case study from the York river in Virginia

The role of human outdoor recreation in shaping patterns of grizzly bear-black bear co-occurrence

The Impact of Message Framing on Wildlife Approach During Ungulate Viewing Experiences in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem

Economic value of protected areas via visitor mental health

Influence of ecotourism on grizzly bear activity depends on salmon abundance in the Atnarko River corridor, Nuxalk Territory

COMPARING FIRE PROTECTION AND IMPROVEMENT VALUES AT FOUR MAJOR US NATIONAL PARKS AND ASSESSING THE POTENTIAL FOR GENERALIZED VALUE CATEGORIES

Economic Valuation of Recreation Use Value of Kilimanjaro National Park, Tanzania

Ecology of fear alters behavior of grizzly bears exposed to bear‐viewing ecotourism

Valuing forest park attributes by giving consideration to the tourist satisfaction

Assessing the Recreational Resource Value of National Park Based on Visitor Perception—A Case of Three-River-Source National Park in China

Valuing Recreational Services of the National Forest Parks Using a Tourist Satisfaction Method

Roles for Wildlife in the Development of Place Meanings Ascribed to a Protected Area

Individual variation in red deer responsiveness towards human disturbance: A prospect for wildlife viewing in Europes national parks.

Analysis of Wildlife Tourism Experiences with Endangered Species: an Exploratory Study of Encounters with Giant Pandas in Chengdu, China

The path to scientifically sound biodiversity valuation in the context of the Global Biodiversity Framework

Tourists' Willingness to Pay for Recreation Services in Nyerere National Park, Tanzania: Are We Overvaluing or Undervaluing Our Nature Recreation Resources?

Characterizing, mapping and valuing the demand for forest recreation using crowdsourced social media data.