Abstract:The human sensorimotor system has a remarkable ability to quickly and efficiently learn movements from sensory experience. A prominent example is sensorimotor adaptation, learning that characterizes the sensorimotor system’s response to persistent sensory errors by adjusting future movements to compensate for those errors. Despite being essential for maintaining and fine-tuning motor control, mechanisms underlying sensorimotor adaptation remain unclear. A component of sensorimotor adaptation is implicit (i.e., the learner is unaware of the learning process) which has been suggested to result from sensory prediction errors–the discrepancies between predicted sensory consequences of motor commands and actual sensory feedback. However, to date no direct neurophysiological evidence that sensory prediction errors drive adaptation has been demonstrated. Here, we examined prediction errors via magnetoencephalography (MEG) imaging of the auditory cortex (n = 34) during sensorimotor adaptation of speech to altered auditory feedback, an entirely implicit adaptation task. Specifically, we measured how speaking-induced suppression (SIS)--a neural representation of auditory prediction errors--changed over the trials of the adaptation experiment. SIS refers to the suppression of auditory cortical response to speech onset (in particular, the M100 response) to self-produced speech when compared to the response to passive listening to identical playback of that speech. SIS was reduced (reflecting larger prediction errors) during the early learning phase compared to the initial unaltered feedback phase. Furthermore, reduction in SIS positively correlated with behavioral adaptation extents, suggesting that larger prediction errors were associated with more learning. In contrast, such a reduction in SIS was not found in a control experiment in which participants heard unaltered feedback and thus did not adapt. In addition, in some participants who reached a plateau in the late learning phase, SIS increased (reflecting smaller prediction errors), demonstrating that prediction errors were minimal when there was no further adaptation. Together, these findings provide the first neurophysiological evidence for the hypothesis that prediction errors drive human sensorimotor adaptation.

Neural correlates of sensorimotor adaptation: thalamic contributions to learning from sensory prediction error

Neurophysiological evidence of sensory prediction errors driving speech sensorimotor adaptation

Progressive changes in functional connectivity between thalamic nuclei and cortical networks across learning

Cooperative thalamocortical circuit mechanism for sensory prediction errors

Task relevance selectively modulates sensorimotor adaptation in the presence of multiple prediction errors.

Learning within a sensory-motor circuit links action to expected outcome

Network state changes in sensory thalamus represent learned outcomes.

Dorsomedial frontal cortex damage impairs error-based, but not reinforcement-based motor learning in humans

Posteromedial cortical networks encode visuomotor prediction errors.

Neural correlates of prediction error in patients with schizophrenia: evidence from an fMRI meta-analysis

Savings in visuomotor learning is associated with connectivity changes within a cerebello-thalamo-cortical network encoding movement errors

The role of the thalamus in human reinforcement learning

Coordinated multi-level adaptations across neocortical areas during task learning

Distinct patterns of connectivity with motor cortex reflect component processes of sensorimotor learning

Competition between parallel sensorimotor learning systems

Mistakes were made: neural mechanisms for the adaptive control of action initiation by the medial prefrontal cortex

The Role of the Lateral Frontal Cortex in Causal Associative Learning: Exploring Preventative and Super-Learning.

Dopamine neuron ensembles signal the content of sensory prediction errors

Prediction error in implicit adaptation during visually- and memory-guided reaching tasks

Hierarchy of prediction errors shapes the learning of context-dependent sensory representations

Prediction-error signals in anterior cingulate cortex drive task-switching