Prehabilitative/rehabilitative exercise, nutrition, and psychological support for bladder cancer: A scoping review of randomized clinical trials
Logan G. Briggs,Sara C. Parke,Kelsey L. Beck,Debarshi Sinha,Vikram Gill,Matthew J. Van Ligten,Paul A. Bain,Mark D. Tyson II,Haidar M. Abdul‐Muhsin,Jaxon K. Quillen,Christopher A. Dodoo,Arthur J. De Luigi,Nikki L. Branstiter,Quoc‐Dien Trinh,Sarah P. Psutka
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cncr.35608
IF: 6.9209
2024-11-03
Cancer
Abstract:In this scoping review of randomized controlled trials investigating (p)rehabilitative support for patients with bladder cancer, 17 of 24 (71%) tested interventions yielded statistically significant results for the outcome of interest.The most promising interventions for inclusion in multimodal, personalized (p)rehabilitation programs included exercise, stress management training, cognitive training, smoking and alcohol cessation counseling, immunonutrition, stoma education, and penile rehabilitation. Further studies of the cost‐effectiveness and efficacy for caregivers of such interventions are needed. Alluvial diagram of (p)rehabilitative interventions and outcomes for randomized clinical trials included in the scoping review. Interventions with statistically significant positive (SS+) results are indicated in color. Interventions that did not yield SS+ results (no significant difference) are indicated in gray. Phys indicates physical; QOL, quality of life. Diagram was created with the ggplot2 package (version 3.4.4) in R software (version 4.2.2). The study of prehabilitation and rehabilitation ([p]rehabilitation) to alleviate the sequelae of bladder cancer and its treatment has generated numerous opportunities to improve the quality of life of bladder cancer survivors. The authors conducted a scoping review of randomized clinical trials (RCTs) to identify knowledge gaps in and research directions for (p)rehabilitative support for those affected by bladder cancer. The authors systematically searched six databases and synthesized key findings from RCTs conducted from January 1, 2004, through March 15, 2022, that enrolled participants with bladder cancer, survivors, or caregivers in outpatient (p)rehabilitative programs (e.g., exercise, nutrition, or psychological support). Outcomes were characterized according to eight prespecified, clinically relevant categories. The search retrieved 10,968 records, 27 of which met the inclusion criteria, and 24 described unique RCTs with 2471 enrolled participants. Of 24 interventions, 17 (71%) yielded statistically significant results for the outcome of interest. Only one RCT included a cost‐effectiveness analysis, and only two characterized the efficacy of interventions for caregivers. Of 11 RCTs involving psychological support, eight yielded statistically significant results, as did nine of 11 RCTs with physical exercise interventions, three of four RCTs with educational interventions, three of four RCTs with nutritional support interventions, one of two RCTs with pharmacologic medications, and zero of one RCT with physical therapy. The most promising interventions for inclusion in multimodal, personalized (p)rehabilitation programs included exercise, stress management training, cognitive training, smoking and alcohol cessation counseling, immunonutrition, stoma education, and penile rehabilitation. Further studies of the cost effectiveness and efficacy for caregivers of such interventions are needed. Plain Language Summary In a scoping review of all randomized clinical trials involving prehabilitative or rehabilitative diet, exercise, and psychological support interventions for patients with bladder cancer, survivors, and their caregivers, 17 of 24 (71%) interventions yielded statistically significant improvements in the outcome of interest. Clinicians should consider implementing such interventions for those affected by bladder cancer.
oncology