Abstract:Total electron content (TEC) is a vital parameter for describing the state of the ionosphere, and precise prediction of TEC is of great significance for improving the accuracy of the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS). At present, most deep learning prediction models just consider TEC temporal variation, while ignoring the impact of spatial location. In this paper, we propose a TEC prediction model, ED-ConvLSTM, which combines convolutional neural networks with recurrent neural networks to simultaneously consider spatiotemporal features. Our ED-ConvLSTM model is built based on the encoder-decoder architecture, which includes two modules: encoder module and decoder module. Each module is composed of ConvLSTM cells. The encoder module is used to extract the spatiotemporal features from TEC maps, while the decoder module converts spatiotemporal features into predicted TEC maps. We compared the predictive performance of our model with two traditional time series models: LSTM, GRU, a spatiotemporal mode1 ConvGRU, and the TEC daily forecast product C1PG provided by CODE on a total of 135 grid points in East Asia (10°–45°N, 90°–130°E). The experimental results show that the prediction error indicators MAE, RMSE, MAPE, and prediction similarity index SSIM of our model are superior to those of the comparison models in high, normal, and low solar activity years. The paper also analyzed the predictive performance of each model monthly. The experimental results indicate that the predictive performance of each model is influenced by the monthly mean of TEC. The ED-ConvLSTM model proposed in this paper is the least affected and the most stable by the monthly mean of TEC. Additionally, the paper compared the predictive performance of each model during two magnetic storm periods when TEC changes sharply. The results indicate that our ED-ConvLSTM model is least affected during magnetic storms and its predictive performance is superior to those of the comparative models. This paper provides a more stable and high-performance TEC spatiotemporal prediction model.

Machine Learning Prediction of Storm‐time High‐latitude Ionospheric Irregularities from GNSS‐derived ROTI Maps

A storm-time ionospheric TEC model with multichannel features by the spatiotemporal ConvLSTM network

The Short-Term Prediction of Low-Latitude Ionospheric Irregularities Leveraging a Hybrid Ensemble Model

A Regional Ionospheric Storm Forecasting Method Using a Deep Learning Algorithm: LSTM

ED‐AttConvLSTM: An Ionospheric TEC Map Prediction Model Using Adaptive Weighted Spatiotemporal Features

Prediction of GNSS-Based Regional Ionospheric TEC Using a Multichannel ConvLSTM With Attention Mechanism

Machine Learning-Based Short-Term GPS TEC Forecasting During High Solar Activity and Magnetic Storm Periods

Prediction of Global Ionospheric TEC based on Deep Learning

Deep Learning‐Based Prediction of Global Ionospheric TEC During Storm Periods: Mixed CNN‐BiLSTM Method

Ionospheric VTEC Prediction Model in Low-Latitude Regions Based on LSTM Neural Network

A short-term prediction model of global ionospheric VTEC based on the combination of long short-term memory and convolutional long short-term memory

Operational Forecasting of Global Ionospheric TEC Maps 1-, 2-, and 3-Day in Advance by ConvLSTM Model

Ionospheric vertical total electron content prediction model in low-latitude regions based on long short-term memory neural network

Forecast of Ionospheric TEC Maps Using ConvGRU Deep Learning Over China

Global forecasting of ionospheric vertical total electron contents via ConvLSTM with spectrum analysis

Deep Learning‐Based Regional Ionospheric Total Electron Content Prediction—Long Short‐Term Memory (LSTM) and Convolutional LSTM Approach

ROTI-based statistical regression models for GNSS precise point positioning errors associated with ionospheric plasma irregularities

Short-Term Prediction of Ionospheric 3D Electron Density in Low Latitude Region Based on LSTM Neural Network

Spatiotemporal Prediction of Ionospheric Total Electron Content Based on ED-ConvLSTM

Ionospheric TEC prediction using Long Short-Term Memory deep learning network

Forecasting Ionospheric TEC using least squares support vector machine and moth-flame optimization methods in China