Factors Associated with and Impact of Open Conversion in Laparoscopic and Robotic Minor Liver Resections: An International Multicenter Study of 10,541 Patients
Mansour Saleh,Franco Pascual,Mohammed Ghallab,Andrew G R Wu,Ken-Min Chin,Francesca Ratti,Mariano Cesare Giglio,Marco Garatti,Phan Phuoc Nghia,Yutaro Kato,Chetana Lim,Paulo Herman,Fabricio Ferreira Coelho,Moritz Schmelzle,Johann Pratschke,Davit L Aghayan,Qiu Liu,Marco V Marino,Andrea Belli,Adrian K H Chiow,Iswanto Sucandy,Arpad Ivanecz,Fabrizio Di Benedetto,Sung Hoon Choi,Jae Hoon Lee,James O Park,Mikel Prieto,Yoelimar Guzman,Constantino Fondevila,Mikhail Efanov,Fernando Rotellar,Gi-Hong Choi,Ricardo Robles-Campos,Prashant Kadam,Robert P Sutcliffe,Roberto I Troisi,Chung Ngai Tang,Charing C Chong,Mathieu D'Hondt,Bernardo Dalla Valle,Andrea Ruzzenente,T Peter Kingham,Olivier Scatton,Rong Liu,Alejandro Mejia,Kohei Mishima,Go Wakabayashi,Santiago Lopez-Ben,Xiaoying Wang,Alessandro Ferrero,Giuseppe Maria Ettorre,Marco Vivarelli,Vincenzo Mazzaferro,Felice Giuliante,Chee Chien Yong,Mengqiu Yin,Kazuteru Monden,David Geller,Kuo-Hsin Chen,Atsushi Sugioka,Bjørn Edwin,Tan-To Cheung,Tran Cong Duy Long,Mohammad Abu Hilal,Luca Aldrighetti,Olivier Soubrane,David Fuks,Ho-Seong Han,Daniel Cherqui,Brian K P Goh,International Robotic and Laparoscopic Liver Resection Study Group Investigators,Mikel Gastaca,Juul Meurs,Celine De Meyere,Eric C H Lai,Felix Krenzien,Kit-Fai Lee,Pavel Tarakanov,Ruslan Alikhanov,Nita Thiruchelvam,Jae Young Jang,Kevin P Labadie,Masayuki Kojima,Asmund Avdem Fretland,Jacob Ghotbi,Jaime Arthur Pirola Kruger,Victor Lopez-Lopez,Paolo Magistri,Giammauro Berardi,Marco Colasanti,Margarida Casellas I Robert,Edoardo Poletto,Federica Cipriani,Mizelle D'Silva,Roberto Montalti,Hao-Ping Wang,Shian Yu,Zewei Chen,Simone Vani,Francesco Ardito,Ugo Giustizieri,Davide Citterio,Federico Mocchegiani,Fabio Forchino,Epameinondas Dogeas,Tiing Foong Siow
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1245/s10434-024-15498-0
Abstract:Introduction: Despite the increasing widespread adoption and experience in minimally invasive liver resections (MILR), open conversion occurs not uncommonly even with minor resections and as been reported to be associated with inferior outcomes. We aimed to identify risk factors for and outcomes of open conversion in patients undergoing minor hepatectomies. We also studied the impact of approach (laparoscopic or robotic) on outcomes. Methods: This is a post-hoc analysis of 20,019 patients who underwent RLR and LLR across 50 international centers between 2004-2020. Risk factors for and perioperative outcomes of open conversion were analysed. Multivariate and propensity score-matched analysis were performed to control for confounding factors. Results: Finally, 10,541 patients undergoing either laparoscopic (LLR; 89.1%) or robotic (RLR; 10.9%) minor liver resections (wedge resections, segmentectomies) were included. Multivariate analysis identified LLR, earlier period of MILR, malignant pathology, cirrhosis, portal hypertension, previous abdominal surgery, larger tumor size, and posterosuperior location as significant independent predictors of open conversion. The most common reason for conversion was technical issues (44.7%), followed by bleeding (27.2%), and oncological reasons (22.3%). After propensity score matching (PSM) of baseline characteristics, patients requiring open conversion had poorer outcomes compared with successful MILR cases as evidenced by longer operative times, more blood loss, higher requirement for perioperative transfusion, longer duration of hospitalization and higher morbidity, reoperation, and 90-day mortality rates. Conclusions: Multiple risk factors were associated with conversion of MILR even for minor hepatectomies, and open conversion was associated with significantly poorer perioperative outcomes.