Management of partial extensor tendon lacerations of the hand and forearm: A national survey of practice in the United Kingdom

Alistair JM Reed,Ryckie G Wade,Justin CR Wormald,Kathryn Dickson,Angelos Mantelakis,David Izadi,Dominic Furniss
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjps.2024.11.028
IF: 3.022
2024-11-28
Journal of Plastic Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery
Abstract:Background Partial extensor tendon lacerations of the hand and forearm are common. There is a lack of evidence to guide management and it is unclear at what threshold surgeons would consider repair necessary. The aim of this study was to identify national surgical management of partial extensor tendon lacerations of the hand and forearm (zones 2-8) and to assess surgeons' willingness to randomise to a future trial. Methods A 34-item online survey was developed by the steering group and, via a trainee-led collaborative model, was disseminated to UK plastic and orthopaedic surgeons. Summary data were calculated for each survey item, and variation between zone and specialty were explored using linear regression. Results 142 complete responses were recorded (response rate 71%). On average, respondents said that 46% tendon division was the maximum they would manage in clinical practice without surgical repair. There was no significant difference in this percentage between zones or surgical specialty. Importantly, the majority (83%) of surgeons would be willing to randomise patients in a clinical trial to repair versus no-repair, within a range of 29-61% tendon division, demonstrating clinical equipoise. Conclusions There is significant variation in UK practice regarding the surgical management of partial extensor tendon lacerations of the hand and forearm and clinical equipoise exists regarding the decision to repair or not. A definitive randomised trial is warranted to identify optimum management of this common injury.
surgery
What problem does this paper attempt to address?