Abstract:Despite its important applications in Machine Learning, min-max optimization of nonconvex-nonconcave objectives remains elusive. Not only are there no known first-order methods converging even to approximate local min-max points, but the computational complexity of identifying them is also poorly understood. In this paper, we provide a characterization of the computational complexity of the problem, as well as of the limitations of first-order methods in constrained min-max optimization problems with nonconvex-nonconcave objectives and linear constraints. As a warm-up, we show that, even when the objective is a Lipschitz and smooth differentiable function, deciding whether a min-max point exists, in fact even deciding whether an approximate min-max point exists, is NP-hard. More importantly, we show that an approximate local min-max point of large enough approximation is guaranteed to exist, but finding one such point is PPAD-complete. The same is true of computing an approximate fixed point of Gradient Descent/Ascent. An important byproduct of our proof is to establish an unconditional hardness result in the Nemirovsky-Yudin model. We show that, given oracle access to some function $f : P \to [-1, 1]$ and its gradient $\nabla f$, where $P \subseteq [0, 1]^d$ is a known convex polytope, every algorithm that finds a $\varepsilon$-approximate local min-max point needs to make a number of queries that is exponential in at least one of $1/\varepsilon$, $L$, $G$, or $d$, where $L$ and $G$ are respectively the smoothness and Lipschitzness of $f$ and $d$ is the dimension. This comes in sharp contrast to minimization problems, where finding approximate local minima in the same setting can be done with Projected Gradient Descent using $O(L/\varepsilon)$ many queries. Our result is the first to show an exponential separation between these two fundamental optimization problems.

Complexity of a class of first-order objective-function-free optimization algorithms

Complexity of a Class of First-Order Objective-Function-Free Optimization Algorithms

Complexity of Adagrad and other first-order methods for nonconvex optimization problems with bounds constraints

A Stochastic Objective-Function-Free Adaptive Regularization Method with Optimal Complexity

Accelerated First-Order Optimization under Nonlinear Constraints

Optimization with First Order Algorithms

Uniformly Optimal and Parameter-free First-order Methods for Convex and Function-constrained Optimization

Worst-case evaluation complexity and optimality of second-order methods for nonconvex smooth optimization

The estimation error of general first order methods

High Probability Complexity Bounds for Non-Smooth Stochastic Optimization with Heavy-Tailed Noise

High-Probability Complexity Bounds for Non-smooth Stochastic Convex Optimization with Heavy-Tailed Noise

Stochastic Optimization for Nonconvex Problem with Inexact Hessian Matrix, Gradient, and Function

The complexity of first-order optimization methods from a metric perspective

First- and Second-Order High Probability Complexity Bounds for Trust-Region Methods with Noisy Oracles

Stochastic Optimization for Non-convex Problem with Inexact Hessian Matrix, Gradient, and Function

How Free is Parameter-Free Stochastic Optimization?

First-order algorithms for robust optimization problems via convex-concave saddle-point Lagrangian reformulation

Convergence of successive linear programming algorithms for noisy functions

Asymptotic error analysis for stochastic gradient optimization schemes with first and second order modified equations

The Complexity of Constrained Min-Max Optimization

On complexity constants of linear and quadratic models for derivative-free trust-region algorithms