A comparative study on walking accessibility of high-speed railway station areas in China and Japan based on analytic hierarchy process -- Beijing station and Osaka station as examples

Wangyang Gui,Tong Zhang,Dingyu Cui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13467581.2023.2299723

IF: 0.904

2024-01-12

Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering

Abstract:To capture the factors influencing and measurements of pedestrian accessibility to high-speed rail station areas, ensure the balance between the transportation function and place performance of high-speed railway station areas, the correlation factors and laws of pedestrian space characteristics of high-speed railway station areas under different development modes are studied through the comparison of typical high-speed railway station areas in China and Japan. Combining the circle law and hierarchical analysis method, we establish a walking accessibility index system, construct a walking accessibility evaluation model for the high-speed rail station area, measure the degree of walking accessibility in the high-speed rail station area, and analyze the influence mechanism of different walking space components on the walking accessibility of the high-speed rail station area circle. The results indicate that: 1) Osaka Station space is much more walkable than Beijing Station in all circles; 2) The spatial development within the Beijing Station Station Circle is uneven, and the degree of pedestrian accessibility decreases as the circle's extent increases; 3)Different station spaces have their own advantages and disadvantages in terms of the distribution of public facilities and amenities, roadway attributes, pedestrian path characteristics, depending on their respective national conditions and station development patterns.

construction & building technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue this paper attempts to address is the evaluation and comparison of the walkability of high-speed railway station areas in China and Japan, specifically using Beijing Station and Osaka Station as examples. By analyzing the characteristics of the walking spaces in high-speed railway station areas under different development models, the paper aims to ensure a balance between the transportation function and the place performance of these areas. Specifically, the study aims to:

1. **Evaluate walkability**: Measure the degree of walkability in high-speed railway station areas by establishing a walkability evaluation model.
2. **Analyze influencing mechanisms**: Explore the mechanisms by which different walking space components affect the walkability of high-speed railway station areas.
3. **Identify improvement measures**: Identify interventions that can improve walkability by comparing the walkability of Beijing Station and Osaka Station, providing references for optimizing the walking space environment of high-speed railway station areas in China.
4. **Promote station-city integrated development**: Enhance the integration of station areas with cities by improving walkability, creating sustainable low-carbon cities.

The research background emphasizes that under the new global trend of green and low-carbon development, low-carbon travel is gradually gaining public attention. As a crucial pillar of the public transportation system, the walkability of high-speed railway station areas is not only related to the functional efficiency of the station areas but also to the economic development of the surrounding areas and the quality of life of residents. Therefore, how to effectively measure and optimize the walking environment of high-speed railway station areas, quickly handle the passenger flow brought by high-speed railway stations, and reasonably utilize these resources to develop or revitalize the station areas and surrounding economies has become a new issue that urgently needs to be addressed.