Abstract:What is the current state of resolving the issue of surplus embryos in Italy, in the absence of clear legislation? This paper proposes organic reform of Italian law and European harmonization for informed and conscious patient decision-making on excess embryos. According to Italian law, embryos obtained through in-vitro fertilization for assisted reproduction that have not reached the transfer phase (including unsuitable ones) cannot be destroyed, resulting in significant resource allocation for indefinite preservation in biobanks. This stems from the legal and ethical recognition of the human embryo as a subject of rights that in turn prohibits destruction, donation to other couples, or use for scientific research. My study compares European legal systems and analyzes the evolution of Italian law on medically assisted fertilization (L. 40/2004) since its implementation, with a focus on legal and ethical issues that have been subject of ongoing debate. It also examines the Italian Ministerial Guidelines, the only text where the legislator has dealt with the issue of surplus embryos. Not applicable. The present study examines the various approaches taken by countries to address the issue of surplus embryos. Regulations in countries such as Spain, France were taken into consideration. The British legal system is also examined for its regulations on the donation of embryos and reproductive cells. The Spanish regulation of embryo-sharing (L. 14/2006) is the most organic approach. It grants three options to couples with respect to their remaining embryos: preservation for personal use, donation to other couples, or donation for research. In the United States, the increase in cryopreserved and abandoned blastocysts has led to the spread of conditional embryo adoption and Snowflakes adoption. The Italian provision, however, fails to adequately balance the constitutionally protected interests of couples' self-determination and scientific research for the protection of individual and collective health. Role of chance not applicable here. Not applicable. Italian legislation neglecting to intervene has caused numerous issues, such as increased costs for fertility centers and poor practices. Clinics advertising embryo adoption, despite regulatory uncertainty, have created unfair competition leading to psychological distress for couples with cells in limbo and fears of financial obligations. NOT APPLICABLE

Current status and disposition suggestions of surplus cryopreservation embryos

Ethical Concideration on the Disposition Decision of Frozen Embryos

Ethics and management of surplus embryos for research

Patients' attitudes towards the surplus frozen embryos in China.

Disposition of unused cryopreserved embryos: opportunities and liabilities

Clinical application of vitrification freezing of oocytes

Study on the Legal and Ethical Issues in the Disposal of Frozen Embryos

Discussion on the Transfer of Human Gamete and Embryos

Too many embryos: a critical perspective on a global challenge

Ethical evaluation on elective oocyte cryopreservation

Embryo cryopreservation and utilization in the United States from 2004-2013

Safety of embryo cryopreservation: insights from mid-term placental transcriptional changes

A brief account of the assessment of the human assisted reproduction technology in China

On Disposal of in Vitro Embryos

Embryo Donation: Medical Aspects

Cryopreservation of Mammalian Oocytes and Embryos: Current Problems and Future Perspectives

Efficiency and safety of vitrification of surplus oocytes following superovulation: a comparison of different clinical indications of oocyte cryopreservation in IVF/ICSI cycles

Abandoned frozen embryos in Argentina: a committee opinion

P-381 "An Analysis of the Legal Gaps and Jurisprudential Paradigms Surrounding Supernumerary Embryos in Italy: A Comparative Law Approach to Propose Practical Solutions"

[Evaluation for the Clinical Application of All Embryos Cryopreservation: a Multi-Centre Study in Northern Area of China].

Retrospective Analysis of Clinical Outcome in Frozen-thawed Embryo Transfer Cycles