The effect of bulk rock composition in phase equilibria modelling: a case study of mafic granulites from the North China Craton

Lei Zou,Jing-Hui Guo,Guang-Yu Huang,Shu-Juan Jiao,Zhong-Hua Tian,Ping-Hua Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00410-022-01887-9
IF: 4.1068
2022-01-28
Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
Abstract:A mafic granulite with relatively simple mineralogy and texture from the Miyun Complex in the northern part of the North China Craton is used to discuss the effect of bulk composition uncertainty determined by different techniques [X-ray fluorescence (XRF), mapping, and point counting] on the calculated phase diagrams. LA-ICP-MS U–Pb dating of zircon from this mafic granulite yields magmatic ages of ~ 2.5–2.45 Ga and metamorphic overprinting ages of ~ 1.8 Ga, consistent with previous results. Based on phase equilibrium modelling, we show that the topological relations of the P–T pseudo-sections calculated from the XRF and point-counting compositions are similar except for the K-feldspar and Fe–Ti oxide stability fields and that the mineral stability fields in the P–T pseudo-section calculated from the mapping composition are distinctly different from the others. Furthermore, the observed and calculated mineral compositions (XAn in plagioclase) and mineral proportions (garnet and plagioclase) are matched in the P–T pseudo-section calculated from the point-counting composition, but these are mismatched in the P–T pseudo-section calculated from the mapping composition. For the P–T pseudo-section calculated from the XRF composition, mineral composition isopleths can further constrain the narrow P–T conditions but the observed and calculated mineral proportions do not match. Moreover, we obtain similar T conditions using geo-thermometers (Ti-in-amphibole, two-feldspar, and REE-in-Grt-Cpx geo-thermometers). In addition, we calculated the uncertainties (of the phase-in/out lines and the mineral-proportions and -compositions isopleths) on the thermodynamic modelling and discussed the main source of uncertainties in detail.
geochemistry & geophysics,mineralogy
What problem does this paper attempt to address?