Abstract:While it is well noted the importance of pursuing inclusive finance to accelerate economic growth and financial sustainability, few actionable insights have been developed toward how financial institutions can balance the potential socioeconomic trade-off between equality and profitability. The challenges are largely three-folds: (1) lack of sufficient information (collateral); (2) lack of understanding of the impact of information on financial equality beyond economic profitability; and (3) lack of real-world causal evaluations under a (large) alternative set of counterfactual policies. Enlightened by the emerging sources of digitized user-behavior data (a.k.a. “alternative data”) enabled by the high penetration of mobile devices and internet access, we study how alternative data from smartphones and social media can help mitigate the potential financial inequality while preserving business profitability in the context of financial credit risk assessment. For evaluation, we partnered with a leading microloan platform and designed a “meta” field experiment that allowed us to recover and compare the “what-if” scenarios in the real world under an exhaustive set of counterfactual policies. Interestingly, we find that compared to using online social media information, profiling user financial risk using smartphone activities is 1.3 times more effective in improving financial inclusion (an increase of 23.05% vs. 18.11%), and likewise 1.3 times more effective in improving business profitability (an increase of 42% vs. 33%). Surprisingly, using consumers’ online shopping activities for credit risk profiling can hurt financial inclusion. Furthermore, we investigate the potential underlying mechanism for improved financial inclusion. Our findings suggest that alternative data, especially users’ smartphone activities, not only demonstrate higher ubiquity but also appear more orthogonal to conventional sensitive demographic attributes. This, in turn, can help better mitigate the statistical bias driven by unobserved factors or under-representative training samples during machine-based risk assessment processes.

Understanding the factors behind racial and ethnic disparities in the adoption of alternative financial services: a decomposition analysis

Exploring Causes, Effects, and Solutions to Financial Illiteracy and Exclusion among Minority Demographic Groups

Profit vs. Equality? The Case of Financial Risk Assessment and A New Perspective of Alternative Data

Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Mortgage Lending: New Evidence from Expanded HMDA Data

Decomposition analysis to identify intervention targets for reducing disparities

Banks, alternative institutions and the spatial–temporal ecology of racial inequality in US cities

Lender Automation and Racial Disparities in Credit Access

An Examination of Demographic Differences in Obtaining Investment and Financial Planning Information

Law and order? Associations between payday lending prohibition and alternative financial services use by degree of enforcement

Are Demographic Variable the Effective Indicator to Predict Credit Debt Behavior

Racial Disparities in Debt Collection

Against the odds: Unveiling the racial dynamics of financial resilience in post‐apartheid South Africa

The Impact of Financial Literacy, Generation, and Socioeconomic Factors on Financial Risk Tolerance: An African American Study

Alternative Finance in the International Business Context, A Review and Future Research

Ethno-racial stratification in the mortgage market: The role of co-applicants

Debt‐based welfare: Debt‐to‐asset relationships across Black and White households in the United States

Racial Disparities in Access to Small Business Credit: Evidence from the Paycheck Protection Program

A case for race and space in auto ownership modeling: A Los Angeles County study

Credit Risk, Regulatory Costs and Lending Discrimination in Efficient Residential Mortgage Markets

Algorithm-Assisted Decision Making and Racial Disparities in Housing: A Study of the Allegheny Housing Assessment Tool

Disentangling effects of ethnicity, deprivation, and payment source on obstetric outcomes in American primigravidae: A structural equation model of observational data.