Abstract:Understanding how cooperation can evolve in populations despite its cost to individual cooperators is an important challenge. Models of spatially structured populations with one individual per node of a graph have shown that cooperation, modeled via the prisoner's dilemma, can be favored by natural selection. These results depend on microscopic update rules, which determine how birth, death, and migration on the graph are coupled. Recently, we developed coarse-grained models of spatially structured populations on graphs, where each node comprises a well-mixed deme, and where migration is independent from division and death, thus bypassing the need for update rules. Here, we study the evolution of cooperation in these models in the rare-migration regime, within the prisoner's dilemma. We find that cooperation is not favored by natural selection in these coarse-grained models on graphs where overall deme fitness does not directly impact migration from a deme. This is due to a separation of scales, whereby cooperation occurs at a local level within demes, while spatial structure matters between demes. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.109.024307 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand how cooperative behavior evolves in structured populations, especially in graph structures where each node contains a deme (a mixed group). Specifically, the researchers developed a coarse - grained model, in which each node represents a deme, and migration is independent of the fission and death processes. They focused on whether cooperative behavior can be favored by natural selection in these models within the framework of the Prisoner's Dilemma game.
### Background and Problem Description of the Paper
1. **Challenges of Cooperative Behavior**:
- Cooperative behavior is widespread in biology and human society, but cooperation usually has a cost to the individual itself. Therefore, understanding how cooperative behavior evolves under the pressure of natural selection is an important scientific problem.
- Traditional theoretical models show that under certain specific update rules, spatial structure can promote the evolution of cooperative behavior. However, these models usually assume that there is only one individual at each node, and the update rules determine the birth, death, and migration processes of individuals.
2. **Proposal of a New Model**:
- The researchers proposed a new model in which each node contains a deme, and migration is independent of the fission and death processes. This model does not require specific update rules, thus simplifying the complexity of the model.
- This model specifically focuses on whether cooperative behavior can be favored by natural selection under rare migration conditions.
### Main Research Questions
- **Evolution of Cooperative Behavior under Rare Migration Conditions**:
- Under rare migration conditions, the researchers explored whether cooperative behavior can be favored by natural selection in these new models.
- They used the Prisoner's Dilemma game to simulate cooperative behavior, where the payoffs and costs of cooperators are represented by a payoff matrix.
- **Influence of Spatial Structure**:
- The researchers analyzed the influence of different types of graph structures (such as complete graphs, ring graphs, star graphs, etc.) on the evolution of cooperative behavior.
- They specifically focused on whether the fixation probability of cooperative behavior in these graph structures is higher than that of neutral mutants.
### Key Findings
- **Fixation Probability of Cooperative Behavior**:
- The research results show that under rare migration conditions, cooperative behavior is not favored by natural selection in these new models. This is because cooperative behavior mainly occurs within local demes, and the influence of spatial structure is mainly reflected in the interactions between demes.
- Specifically, the fixation probability of cooperative behavior is similar to that of mutants with a fixed fitness disadvantage, indicating that the influence of spatial structure on the evolution of cooperative behavior is limited.
- **Comparison of Different Graph Structures**:
- For complete graphs and ring graphs, the fixation probability of cooperative behavior is not affected by migration asymmetry.
- For star graphs, the fixation probability of cooperative behavior is affected by migration asymmetry. When the immigration rate is greater than the emigration rate, natural selection is amplified; otherwise, it is suppressed.
### Conclusion
This paper explored the evolution mechanism of cooperative behavior in structured populations by developing a new coarse - grained model. The research results show that under rare migration conditions, cooperative behavior is not favored by natural selection in these models, mainly because cooperative behavior mainly occurs within local demes, and the influence of spatial structure is mainly reflected in the interactions between demes. This finding provides a new perspective for understanding the evolution of cooperative behavior.