A REB-reading of cholinesterase inhibitors' effect on all-cause mortality in patients with dementia

Clara Blanchard,Flore Laforest,Hélène Vaillant-Roussel,Rémy Boussageon
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111396
IF: 7.407
2024-05-24
Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
Abstract:We propose a new reading of the results of a solid systematic review published in 2022 in Neurology by Truong et al comparing ChEI treatment to placebo or no treatment on all-cause mortality in patients with any type of dementia. Leaving ethical considerations aside, we tested if another method of interpretation of the results of the systematic review would yield different results. We applied the "rebuild the evidence base" (REB) method to the data extracted from the meta-analysis and found that the positive result of the meta-analysis ( p =0.01) and the lack of heterogeneity did not weigh enough in the balance against the strictly exploratory nature of all the results of the individual RCTs included and the suspected publication bias. There was a lack of evidence of effect of ChEI treatment on over-all mortality in patients with dementia.
public, environmental & occupational health,health care sciences & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?