Logical Reasoning Ability and Teacher Verbal Behavior within the Mathematics Classroom
Alan R. Osborne,J. W. Gregory
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5951/JRESEMATHEDUC.6.1.0026
Abstract:The development of logical skills is a goal held by most educators. Yet reported research offers little of a prescriptive nature concerning how to nurture and enhance children's ability to use logic. There have been a few attempts to teach children logic per se. (Donaldson; 1963; Suppes & Binford, 1965; McAloon, 1969; Miller, 1969). For the most part, these studies reported that children have learned principles of logic. But those studies that report comparative data for students not receiving formal instruction in logic report equivalent growth between pretest and posttest administrations for both groups. (Ennis & Paulus, 1965; Roy, 1970; Williams, 1971). Another direction of researchers is exploration of correlates of logical reasoning ability and the development process (Bonser, 1910; Burt, 1919; Inhelder & Piaget, 1958; Hill, 1961; Shapiro & O'Brien, 1970). Age and IQ are the only variables that have consistently been found to be related to logical ability. But age and IQ are static or passive variables in the sense of not offering the teacher or experimenter the potential of actively controlling the child's environment to produce growth in logical ability. The purpose of this study was to explore one variable within the mathematics classroom that is subject to the control of the teacher, namely, the ordinary language of the teacher. Several studies of teacher verbal behavior suggested this might be a significant variable. Wright and Proctor (1961), Smith and Meux (1962), Bellack (1965), Gallagher, Ashner, and Jenne (1967), and Fey (1970) have all reported that use of the language of conditional reasoning constitutes a portion of teacher verbal behavior regardless of the subject matter content. Smith and Meux (1962) have been the only investigators to exhibit actual frequencies of the specialized language of logic and conclude that mathematics teachers
Psychology,Mathematics,Education