Institutional Investors' Site Visit and the Methodof Management Earnings Guidance
Xiaoke CHENG,Haoyang LI,Shenghao GAO
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2017.01.012
2017-01-01
Journal of Management Science
Abstract:Management earnings guidance,as an important voluntary disclosure method,is well examined by the academic community.Recent literature increasingly emphasizes the strategic choice of managers on the disclosure time and form of earnings guidance.Hence,it is of great importance to investigate how to prevent managers from opportunistic earnings guidance and improve the precision of earnings guidance.Leveraging the listed firms in Shenzhen Stock Exchange that disclosed management earnings guidance as samples,we investigate the impact of institutional investors' site visits on management earnings guidance and the moderating effect of information attribution and state ownership on the relationship.We measure the frequency of institutional investors' site visits by the natural logarithm of the times of investor visits a firm hosts in one year and the natural logarithm of total investor number a firm hosts in one year.Our dependent variable measures the degree of accuracy of manage earnings guidance,which is equal to 4 when the firm issued a point forecast during a fiscal period,3 when an interval forecast,2 when an open-ended forecast,and 1 when a qualitative forecast.Using ordered logistic regressions,we test the impact of institutional investors' site visit frequency on the accuracy degree of management earnings guidance.We find that the more frequently a firm is visited by institutional investors,the more ambiguous its management earnings guidance is.The above relationship is more pronounced in firms with negative earnings guidance.The aforementioned findings concentrate mainly in non-SOEs.Further analysis shows that sell-side analysts have larger impact than buy-side ones and that there is no difference between mutual and private fund.These results are robust to a set of sensitivity checks,including two-stage least square and Heckman two-stage regressions.Institutional investors,as an important type of market participants,have been focused ever since.The majority of existing literature documents evidence consistent with that the interactions between firm management and institutional investors decrease information asymmetry between them and increase the transparency of firms' information environment.However,we find that the site visits of institutional investors pressure managers to issue more ambiguous earnings guidance,which is in contrast to the traditional view on the function of manager-investor interactions.This shed new light on the effect institutional investors on the information environment of listed firms.Our study will benefit investors in China by deepening their understanding on earnings management guidance and encourage the regulatory agency to improve disclosure system and alleviate the information asymmetry in capital market.