Abstract:Background: Oropharyngeal cancer (OPC) is a widespread disease, with radiotherapy being a core treatment modality. Manual segmentation of the primary gross tumor volume (GTVp) is currently employed for OPC radiotherapy planning, but is subject to significant interobserver variability. Deep learning (DL) approaches have shown promise in automating GTVp segmentation, but comparative (auto)confidence metrics of these models predictions has not been well-explored. Quantifying instance-specific DL model uncertainty is crucial to improving clinician trust and facilitating broad clinical implementation. Therefore, in this study, probabilistic DL models for GTVp auto-segmentation were developed using large-scale PET/CT datasets, and various uncertainty auto-estimation methods were systematically investigated and benchmarked. Methods: We utilized the publicly available 2021 HECKTOR Challenge training dataset with 224 co-registered PET/CT scans of OPC patients with corresponding GTVp segmentations as a development set. A separate set of 67 co-registered PET/CT scans of OPC patients with corresponding GTVp segmentations was used for external validation. Two approximate Bayesian deep learning methods, the MC Dropout Ensemble and Deep Ensemble, both with five submodels, were evaluated for GTVp segmentation and uncertainty performance. The segmentation performance was evaluated using the volumetric Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), mean surface distance (MSD), and Hausdorff distance at 95% (95HD). The uncertainty was evaluated using four measures from literature: coefficient of variation (CV), structure expected entropy, structure predictive entropy, and structure mutual information, and additionally with our novel Dice-risk measure. The utility of uncertainty information was evaluated with the accuracy of uncertainty-based segmentation performance prediction using the Accuracy vs Uncertainty (AvU) metric, and by examining the linear correlation between uncertainty estimates and DSC. In addition, batch-based and instance-based referral processes were examined, where the patients with high uncertainty were rejected from the set. In the batch referral process, the area under the referral curve with DSC (R-DSC AUC) was used for evaluation, whereas in the instance referral process, the DSC at various uncertainty thresholds were examined. Results: Both models behaved similarly in terms of the segmentation performance and uncertainty estimation. Specifically, the MC Dropout Ensemble had 0.776 DSC, 1.703 mm MSD, and 5.385 mm 95HD. The Deep Ensemble had 0.767 DSC, 1.717 mm MSD, and 5.477 mm 95HD. The uncertainty measure with the highest DSC correlation was structure predictive entropy with correlation coefficients of 0.699 and 0.692 for the MC Dropout Ensemble and the Deep Ensemble, respectively. The highest AvU value was 0.866 for both models. The best performing uncertainty measure for both models was the CV which had R-DSC AUC of 0.783 and 0.782 for the MC Dropout Ensemble and Deep Ensemble, respectively. With referring patients based on uncertainty thresholds from 0.85 validation DSC for all uncertainty measures, on average the DSC improved from the full dataset by 4.7% and 5.0% while referring 21.8% and 22% patients for MC Dropout Ensemble and Deep Ensemble, respectively. Conclusion: We found that many of the investigated methods provide overall similar but distinct utility in terms of predicting segmentation quality and referral performance. These findings are a critical first-step towards more widespread implementation of uncertainty quantification in OPC GTVp segmentation.

Uncertainty-informed deep learning models enable high-confidence predictions for digital histopathology

Joint Dermatological Lesion Classification and Confidence Modeling with Uncertainty Estimation

Predictive uncertainty estimation in deep learning for lung carcinoma classification in digital pathology under real dataset shifts

The use of artificial intelligence with uncertainty estimation to predict lung cancer relapse from histopathology.

Predictive uncertainty estimation for out-of-distribution detection in digital pathology

Uncertainty Quantification in Computer-Aided Diagnosis: Make Your Model say "I don't know" for Ambiguous Cases

Leveraging Uncertainty in Deep Learning for Pancreatic Adenocarcinoma Grading

Deep learning uncertainty quantification for clinical text classification

Deep Learning with Uncertainty Quantification for Predicting the Segmentation Dice Coefficient of Prostate Cancer Biopsy Images

Quantifying and leveraging predictive uncertainty for medical image assessment

Application of simultaneous uncertainty quantification for image segmentation with probabilistic deep learning: Performance benchmarking of oropharyngeal cancer target delineation as a use-case

Benchmarking common uncertainty estimation methods with histopathological images under domain shift and label noise

Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions

Machine learning enabled prediction of digital biomarkers from whole slide histopathology images

Enhancing a deep learning model for pulmonary nodule malignancy risk estimation in chest CT with uncertainty estimation

Uncertainty-aware image classification on 3D CT lung

A Robust Deep Learning Method with Uncertainty Estimation for the Pathological Classification of Renal Cell Carcinoma based on CT Images

Improving Image-Based Precision Medicine with Uncertainty-Aware Causal Models

Abstract 5012: Deep Gaussian process with uncertainty estimation Improves microsatellite instability prediction based on whole slide image: A retrospective multicenter and multiethnic cohort study

Abstract 7385: Explainable AI model incorporating uncertainty estimation for enhanced MSI-H prediction and immunotherapy response in gastrointestinal cancer

Clinical assessment of deep learning-based uncertainty maps in lung cancer segmentation