Building a Bridge to Community: A Pragmatic Randomized Trial Examining a Combined Physical Therapy and Resistance Exercise Intervention for People after Head and Neck Cancer

Margaret L. McNeely,K. Ming Chan,Ryan A. Spychka,Joni Nedeljak,Brock Debenham,Naresh Jha,Hadi Seikaly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers16091758

2024-05-02

Cancers

Abstract:Background: Established barriers to general exercise and physical activity among individuals with head and neck cancer include dry mouth, difficulty eating, weight loss, fear of injury, comorbidities, and treatment-related symptoms of pain and fatigue. Methods/Design: A 12-week pragmatic randomized controlled trial was conducted followed by an optional supported exercise transition phase. Eligible participants were individuals with head and neck cancers who had undergone surgery and/or radiation therapy to lymph node regions in the neck. Participants were randomized to a comparison group involving a shoulder and neck physiotherapeutic exercise protocol, or to a combined experimental group comprising the shoulder and neck physiotherapeutic exercise protocol and lower-body resistance exercise training. The primary outcome of this study was fatigue-related quality of life. Results: Sixty-one participants enrolled, 59 (97%) completed the randomized trial phase, 55 (90%) completed the 24-week follow-up, and 52 (85%) completed the one-year follow-up. Statistically significant between-group differences were found in favor of the combined experimental group for the fatigue-related quality of life, fitness outcomes, and overall physical activity. Paired comparisons confirmed significant within-group improvements for both groups from baseline to one-year follow-up across most outcomes. Discussion: A group-based combined physiotherapeutic and lower-body resistance exercise program was feasible and effective. Findings are limited to individuals who had undergone a surgical neck dissection procedure. Given the complexity of head and neck cancer, further pragmatic interdisciplinary research is warranted.

oncology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue discussed in this paper is the shoulder and neck dysfunction, weight loss, muscle weakness, and decline in physical function faced by head and neck cancer patients after completing treatment. Through a Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial (PrCT), the study evaluates the impact of adding lower limb resistance training to a physical therapy shoulder and neck exercise program on fatigue-related quality of life.

Specifically, the study aims to:

1. Assess the effectiveness of adding lower limb resistance training to a shoulder and neck physical therapy exercise program in improving fatigue-related quality of life.
2. Evaluate the feasibility of providing interventions in a supervised group format.
3. Explore the benefits of a year-long supportive exercise regimen.

The study included 61 patients who had completed head and neck cancer treatment, randomly dividing them into two groups: one group received only the shoulder and neck physical therapy exercise program (REHAB group); the other group received the same program with the addition of lower limb resistance training (TARGET group). The results showed that the TARGET group had significant improvements in fatigue-related quality of life, six-minute walk test distance, upper and lower limb muscle strength, and overall activity levels. Additionally, the TARGET group continued to show positive effects during the one-year follow-up period, indicating that this interdisciplinary approach helps patients transition from rehabilitative care to general exercise and physical activity.