Abstract:Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, Ahead of Print. Occasionally, problems are solved with a sudden Aha! moment (insight), while the mundane approach to solving problems is analytical (non-insight). At first glance, non-insight appears to depend on the availability and taxation of cognitive resources to execute the step-by-step approach, whereas insight does not, or to a lesser extent. However, this remains debated. To investigate the reliance of both solution types on cognitive resources, we assessed the involvement of the prefrontal cortex using vagally mediated heart rate variability (vmHRV) as an index. Participants (N = 68) solved 70 compound remote associates word puzzles solvable with insight and non-insight. Before, during, and after solving the word puzzles, we measured the vmHRV. Our results showed that resting-state vmHRV (trait) showed a negative association with behavioural performance for both solution types. This might reflect inter-individual differences in inhibitory control. As the solution search requires one to think of remote associations, inhibitory control might hamper rather than aid this process. Furthermore, we observed, for both solution types, a vmHRV increase from resting-state to solution search (state), lingering on in the post-task recovery period. This could mark the increase of prefrontal resources to promote an open-minded stance, essential for divergent thinking, which arguably is crucial for this task. Our findings suggest that, at a general level, both solution types share common aspects. However, a closer analysis of early and late solutions and puzzle difficulty suggested that metacognitive differentiation between insight and non-insight improved with higher trait vmHRV, and that a unique association between trait vmHRV and puzzle difficulty was present for each solution type.

Effects of task characteristics and task-switching on remote associates test problem solving

Protecting against mental impasses: Evidence of selective retrieval mitigating the impact of fixation in creative problem solving

Use or Consequences: Probing the Cognitive Difference Between Two Measures of Divergent Thinking

Competition during verbal creative processes influences on ERS/ERD

Cooperation Makes a Group be More Creative

Moderating Role of Creative Mindset in the Effect of Metacognitive Experience on Insight Problem Solving

The relationship between media multitasking and creativity: a multi-test, multi-method analysis

From Individual Creativity to Team Creativity:The Effect of Knowledge Diversity

Does Metacognition Matter in Creative Problem‐Solving? A Mixed‐Methods Analysis of Writing

Analysis of English free association network reveals mechanisms of efficient solution of Remote Association Tests

The Unconscious Tug-of-War: Exploring the Effect of Stimulus Selection Bias on Creative Problem Solving with Multiple Unconscious Stimuli

Insight and non-insight problem solving: A heart rate variability study

Time Sharing Between Robotics and Process Control: Validating a Model of Attention Switching

Changes in semantic memory structure support successful problem-solving and analogical transfer

Creativity assessment in neuroscience research.

Effect of cognitive load and working memory capacity on the efficiency of discovering better alternatives: A survival analysis

Think Hard or Think Smart: Network Reconfigurations After Divergent Thinking Associate With Creativity Performance

A neural network model of individual differences in task switching abilities

Spillover Effects in Creative Thinking: The Impact of Gaming and Mathematics on Creativity and Emotions

Modeling the Remote Associates Test as Retrievals from Semantic Memory

Do Task Sets Compete in the Stroop Task and Other Selective Attention Paradigms?