Abstract:The analysis of mediation effects is important in education,psychology,and other social sciences research.The approaches used in regression and path analysis for investigating such effects are widely known.These methods,however,are inappropriate if the data are clustered in nature,due to the violation of the assumption of independence of observations and biased standard errors.Therefore,a method for analyzing the mediation effects within multilevel models has been developed and proposed.Several procedures have been recommended and implemented in existing commercial software for testing of mediation effects in multilevel models.But most of these methods assumed that the effects are fixed,even for random indirect model.As a result,it is highly needed to examine the indirect effects under different conditions.There are few studies on this topic in Mainland till now.Following Bauer,Preacher,and Gil's(2006) study,the purpose of the present article focused on the multilevel random mediation effect model(1-1-1) and examined various analytical procedures for random multilevel meditation analysis.The performances of these procedures under different conditions were compared using Monte Carlo simulations method.First,in order to address why multilevel random mediation model is necessary,the improvement in using the random multilevel mediation model compared to two compact models,the multilevel fixed mediation model and the single-level traditional mediation model is examined.Second,three different estimation methods,restricted maximum likelihood estimate(REML),maximum likelihood estimate(MLE),and minimum variance quadratic unbiased estimate(MIVQUE) are compared in different conditions.The results indicate that we can obtain unbiased estimation of the mediation effect,correct standard error,and proper result of hypothesis test through using the multilevel random mediation model,comparing with using the other two compact models.Moreover,the differences of multilevel fixed mediation model and single-level traditional mediation model are trivial.For the estimation random mediation effects in multilevel random mediation model,it is better to use restricted maximum likelihood estimate(REML) and maximum likelihood estimate(MLE),comparing with minimum variance quadratic unbiased estimate(MIVQUE).Only when the model has problem on converging,can one use MIVQUE instead,but researches should pay attention to the reliability of MIVQUE under different conditions.This paper consider the use of multilevel modeling to estimate mediation models in which there is lower level mediation,and all terms are random.It could be concluded that tests of random multilevel mediation can be problematic when more fixed effects models are used.For testing random indirect effects,different estimation methods might reach similar results.The REML method of SAS MIXED procedure is better than that of the MIVQUE method in the studied conditions.Recommendations are provided for testing multilevel mediation.

Autoregressive mediation models using composite scores and latent variables: Comparisons and recommendations.

Multilevel Autoregressive Mediation Models: Specification, Estimation, and Applications

Investigating the Impact of the Time Interval Selection on Autoregressive Mediation Modeling: Result Interpretations, Effect Reporting, and Temporal Designs

Causal Mediation Analysis in the Context of Clinical Research.

Latent Class Dynamic Mediation Model with Application to Smoking Cessation Data

Robust Mediation Analysis Based on Median Regression.

Comparisons of Estimation Methods for Multilevel Random Mediation Effect Model

Individualized Dynamic Mediation Analysis Using Latent Factor Models

A Class of Distribution-Free Models for Longitudinal Mediation Analysis

Causal Models for Mediation Analysis: an Introduction to Structural Mean Models.

Multilevel Random Mediation Analysis: A Comparison of Analytical Alternatives

Signal-to-Noise Ratio in Estimating and Testing the Mediation Effect: Structural Equation Modeling versus Path Analysis with Weighted Composites

Multilevel Analysis of Mediation, Moderation, and Nonlinear Effects in Small Samples, Using Expected a Posteriori Estimates of Factor Scores

Longitudinal mediation analysis through generalised linear mixed models: a comparison of maximum-likelihood and Bayesian estimation

Three-Level Longitudinal Mediation with Nested Units: How Does an Upper-Level Predictor Influence a Lower-Level Outcome Via an Upper-Level Mediator over Time?

Variance component tests of multivariate mediation effects under composite null hypotheses

Impact of Violations of Measurement Invariance in Cross-Lagged Panel Mediation Models

Latent class mediation: A comparison of six approaches

Counterfactual Graphical Models for Longitudinal Mediation Analysis With Unobserved Confounding

Methods for Modeling Autocorrelation and Handling Missing Data in Mediation Analysis in Single Case Experimental Designs (SCEDs)

Handling Measurement Error and Omitted Confounders Considering Informativeness of the Confounding Effect under Mediation Modeling