Abstract:Importance: The prevalence of electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) use is increasing. Population health effects will depend on cigarette smoking behaviors, levels of dual use with conventional cigarettes, and e-cigarette toxicity. Objective: To evaluate potential health effects of various scenarios of increasing promotion and use of e-cigarettes. Design, setting, and participants: A base case model was developed using data on actual cigarette and e-cigarette use patterns that quantifies transitions from an initial state of no cigarette or e-cigarette use to 1 of 5 final states: never use of cigarettes or e-cigarettes, cigarette use, e-cigarette use, dual use of cigarettes and e-cigarettes, or quit. Seven scenarios were created that cover a range of use patterns, depending on how the e-cigarette market might develop, as well as a range of possible long-term health effects of e-cigarette use. Scenarios for changes from the base case were evaluated using Monte Carlo simulations. Separate sets of base case model parameters were evaluated for the US and UK populations. Main outcomes and measures: We assigned unitless health "costs" for each final state on a scale of 0 to 100. Population health "costs" were compared with the base case (status quo) assuming e-cigarette use health "costs" from 1% to 50% as dangerous as conventional cigarette use health costs. Results: Compared with the base case, a harm reduction scenario in which e-cigarette use increases only among smokers who are interested in quitting with more quit attempts and no increased initiation of e-cigarette use among nonsmokers, and another scenario in which e-cigarettes are taken up only by youth who would have smoked conventional cigarettes, had population-level health benefits regardless of e-cigarette health costs in both the United States and United Kingdom. Conversely, scenarios in which e-cigarette promotion leads to renormalization of cigarette smoking or e-cigarettes are used primarily by youth who never would have smoked showed net health harms across all e-cigarette health costs. In other scenarios, the net health effect varied on the basis of the health cost of e-cigarettes. Conclusions and relevance: According to this analysis, widespread promotion of e-cigarettes may have a wide range of population-level health effects, depending on both e-cigarette health risks and patterns of use. Absent the primary effect of e-cigarette promotion being only to divert current or future conventional cigarette smokers to e-cigarette use, the current uncertainty about the health risks of e-cigarettes, increasing e-cigarette use among youth, and the varying health effects at different e-cigarette health costs suggest a potential for harm.

Optimal e-cigarette policy when preferences and internalities are correlated

Optimal Taxation of Cigarettes and E-Cigarettes: Principles for Taxing Reduced-Harm Tobacco Products

Re-exploring the early relationship between teenage cigarette and e-cigarette use using price and tax changes

The association between excise taxes and smoking and vaping transitions-Findings from the 2016-2020 ITC United States surveys

Cost Comparison and Spending on Tobacco Products: Evidence from A Nationally Representative Sample of Adult E-Cigarette Users

Real-world, Anti-Tobacco Environmental Impact Upon Price-Induced Smoking Reduction among Urban Chinese Men: Evidence from China's 2015 Cigarette Tax Increase.

Investigating the Impact of E-Cigarette Price and Tax on E-Cigarette Use Behavior

E-Cigarettes and Adult Smoking: Evidence from Minnesota

Examining the Predictive Utility of Behavioral Economic Demand Indices and Subjective Effects on the Actualized Reinforcing Value of Menthol Cigarettes and Potential Alternatives

How cigarette excise tax pass-through to prices responds to the uptake and evolution of e-cigarettes (ECs)

The effects of traditional cigarette and e-cigarette tax rates on adult tobacco product use

Restrictions of cigarette and e-cigarette flavor and filter ventilation on demand and substitution in the Experimental Tobacco Marketplace

Intended and unintended effects of e-cigarette taxes on youth tobacco use

Using Experimental Auctions to Examine Demand for E-Cigarettes

How does the e-cigarette industry respond to tax adjustments? Evidence from China

Modeling the Health Effects of Expanding e-Cigarette Sales in the United States and United Kingdom: A Monte Carlo Analysis

The price elasticity of heated tobacco and cigarette demand: Empirical evaluation across countries

The association between tax structure and cigarette price variability: findings from the ITC Project

Effect of Massachusetts House Bill No. 4196 on electronic cigarette use: a mixed-methods study

An empirical assessment of effectiveness of the US tobacco control policies: a smoothed instrumental variables quantile regression approach

Cost-effectiveness analysis of e-cigarettes compared to nicotine replacement therapy for smoking cessation among Medicaid users in California