Study on the Design Factors and Modes of Team Compensation Scheme
ZHANG Zheng-tang,WANG ya-bei,LIU Ning
2012-01-01
Abstract:Almost all organizations employ workgroups or teams.With the increasing emphasis on team-based work,team compensation scheme is an important institutional guarantee for the smooth operation of the team.Researchers have documented a growing interest in group-based compensation,or "pay systems in which group members pay is at least partially contingent on measurable group performance".Substantial field evidence exists for the relationship between group incentives andgroup performance.Empirical evidence at the individual level shows that incentives may influence performance,in part,through their influence on goal setting.Additionally,research has shown how organizational contextual variables such as monetary incentives and self-set goal level instructions influence goal valences.Others have studied processes that mediate the relationship between group goals and group performance.However,there is little theoretical study on the design factors and modes of team compensation scheme so far.Based on the pastcompensation theories and practices,this paper considers that the design factors and modes are theoretical premises of the empirical study on the effects of different team compensation schemes. Task interdependence,as a basic characteristic of team work,determines the team compensation inter dependence,and forms two layers of distribution-primary distribution and secondary distribution within the team.The primary distribution is a process in which evaluate the whole performance of team,identify the team contribution and offer rewards to teams.The secondary distribution is to identify the contribution of individuals to team performance and distribute the bonus within the team members.The primary distribution can improve the team recognition and cohesiveness,while the secondary distribution affects directly on the work attitude of team members.The design of team compensation scheme contains several factors such as the performance measurement,performance goal and performance-compensation sensitivity.The different combination of these factors would result in different types of team compensation schemes. This paper discusses some classical models of team compensation scheme.The primary distribution plans include Absolute-Performance-Budget-Based Distribution Plan and Relative-Performance-Target-Based /Competitive Distribution Plan.Specifically,Absolute-Performance-Budget-Base Distribution Plan includes group piece-rate contract,group budget-fixed contract and group budget-linear contract.A group budget-fixed contract provides no remuneration for performance below the budget and a fixed bonus for performance meeting or exceeding the budget.A group budget-linear contract provides no remuneration for performancebelow the budget,a fixed bonus once the budget is attained,plus a piece rate for production in excess of the budget.However,the Competitive Distribution Plan based on Tournament Theory is an incentive plan which is determined by relative performance.It includes 'winner-take-all' plan,competitive ranking plan and team competitive-linear contract.The secondary distribution plans includes Equal-Based,Absolute-Contribution-Based and Relative-Contribution-Based distribution plan.The first plan is often called the Equality distribution plan,while the last two are often called Equity distribution plan.The secondary distribution is to balance the relation between competition and cooperation.That is to say,it should not only assure the equality among employees,but also motivate employee to work hard.Equality distribution plan improves team cooperation,but creates 'free-riding' effect.However,Equity distribution plan promote competition within the team but at the same time hinders the cooperation among team members.The integration of these two layers of distribution plans creates variance kinds of team compensation schemes which are applicable to different situation. At the end,this paper recommends that more theoretical and empirical study on the incentive effect andspecial context of different team compensation schemes should be carried out to help improving the efficiency of compensation decisions in firms.