Facets of Trust and Distrust in Collaborative Robots at the Workplace: Towards a Multidimensional and Relational Conceptualisation

Tobias Kopp
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12369-023-01082-1
IF: 3.802
2024-01-24
International Journal of Social Robotics
Abstract:The relevance of trust on the road to successful human-robot interaction is widely acknowledged. Thereby, trust is commonly understood as a monolithic concept characterising dyadic relations between a human and a robot. However, this conceptualisation seems oversimplified and neglects the specific interaction context. In a multidisciplinary approach, this conceptual analysis synthesizes sociological notions of trust and distrust, psychological trust models, and ideas of philosophers of technology in order to pave the way for a multidimensional, relational and context-sensitive conceptualisation of human-robot trust and distrust. In this vein, trust is characterised functionally as a mechanism to cope with environmental complexity when dealing with ambiguously perceived hybrid robots such as collaborative robots, which enable human-robot interactions without physical separation in the workplace context. Common definitions of trust in the HRI context emphasise that trust is based on concrete expectations regarding individual goals. Therefore, I propose a three-dimensional notion of trust that binds trust to a reference object and accounts for various coexisting goals at the workplace. Furthermore, the assumption that robots represent trustees in a narrower sense is challenged by unfolding influential relational networks of trust within the organisational context. In terms of practical implications, trust is distinguished from acceptance and actual technology usage, which may be promoted by trust, but are strongly influenced by contextual moderating factors. In addition, theoretical arguments for considering distrust not only as the opposite of trust, but as an alternative and coexisting complexity reduction mechanism are outlined. Finally, the article presents key conclusions and future research avenues.
robotics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the issue of trust in human-cobot (collaborative robots) interactions in industrial workplaces and proposes a multidimensional, relational, and context-sensitive conceptual framework. Specifically: - **The Importance of Trust in Human-Robot Interaction**: The paper first emphasizes the critical role of trust in successful human-robot interaction (HRI), especially in industrial environments. Trust not only affects the degree to which humans accept robots but also influences their willingness to rely on robotic actions. - **The Multidimensional Nature of Trust**: The authors propose a three-dimensional concept of trust, binding trust to specific objects and considering the multiple coexisting goals in the workplace. This helps to better understand how trust functions in practical operations. - **The Complexity of Trust**: The paper explores trust as a mechanism to cope with environmental complexity and points out that trust is a dynamically changing process. Trust levels are continuously updated with new experiences, and negative events have a greater impact on trust than positive ones. - **Trust Networks in Organizational Contexts**: The authors challenge the assumption of robots as narrowly defined trustees and reveal the complex network of trust relationships within organizational contexts. These networks include other employees and organizational structures. - **The Role of Distrust**: In addition to trust, the paper discusses the importance of distrust, arguing that distrust is not merely the opposite of trust but a complexity-reducing mechanism that can coexist with trust. In summary, this paper aims to construct a more comprehensive, detailed, and practically applicable conceptual model of human-robot trust through a multidisciplinary approach, integrating perspectives from sociology, psychology, and the philosophy of technology.