Assessing and mitigating potential hazards of emerging grid-scale electrical energy storage systems

Meng Qi,Yulin Liu,Robert Stephen Landon,Yi Liu,Il Moon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psep.2021.03.042

IF: 7.8

2021-05-01

Process Safety and Environmental Protection

Abstract:Electrical energy storage (EES) systems consisting of multiple process components and containing intensive amounts of energy present inherent hazards coupled with high operational risks. Although the thermal hazards of batteries have aroused widespread attention, the safety issues of emerging large scale EES technologies persist. This study aims to begin to fill this gap by examining the hazards of typical 100 MWh or more EES systems which are used for grid applications. These systems include compressed and liquid air energy storage, CO₂ energy storage, thermal storage in concentrating solar power plants, and Power-to-Gas. Hazard assessments are performed using a hybrid method to consider and evaluate the EES systems' potential hazards from three novel aspects: storage, operability, and connectivity. Results reveal that for a similar energy storage capacity, cryogenic liquid systems have the least severe accident consequences while thermal energy storage using synthetic oil exhibits the largest. Concerning the operations in many cases, extreme operating conditions, complicated heat exchanger networks involving multiple flammable working fluids, and system operation intermittency present the major challenges to the safer operation of EES systems. Lastly, these systems themselves form one of many components of the power supply, each of which needs to accommodate fluctuations in supply and demand but also should be prevented from transmitting hazards to each other. Considering both engineering and administrative controls, this paper concludes with a discussion on the four grouped strategies from inherent to procedural for the elimination and mitigation of the identified hazards. Representative solutions and research perspectives including inherently safer design, operation uncertainty management, resilience analysis, energy barriers design, and life cycle safety assessment are suggested for the overall safety enhancement of industrial EES systems.

engineering, environmental, chemical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the potential safety issues faced by large - scale grid - level electrical energy storage systems (EES) during their rapid development and wide application. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to evaluate and mitigate the potential hazards of these emerging large - scale EES systems, especially those with a capacity of 100 MWh or more. The following are the specific problems that the paper attempts to solve:

1. **Identifying potential hazards**:
- The paper aims to evaluate the potential hazards of typical large - scale EES systems (such as compressed - air energy storage, liquefied - air energy storage, carbon - dioxide energy storage, heat energy storage in concentrating solar thermal power generation, and Power - to - Gas technology).
- Consider and evaluate the potential hazards of these EES systems from three new perspectives of storage, operability, and connectivity through a hybrid method.

2. **Analyzing accident consequences**:
- The research results show that for similar energy storage capacities, the accident consequences of cryogenic liquid systems (such as liquefied - air energy storage) are the least severe, while the accident consequences of heat energy storage systems using synthetic oils are the most severe.
- The analysis indicates that extreme operating conditions, complex heat - exchange networks involving multiple flammable working fluids, and the intermittent operation of the system are the main challenges for safer operation.

3. **Proposing mitigation strategies**:
- The paper proposes four types of strategies (inherent safety, active control, passive control, and procedural control) to eliminate and mitigate the identified hazards.
- Representative solutions and research directions, including inherently safer design, operational uncertainty management, resilience analysis, energy barrier design, and life - cycle safety assessment, are recommended to improve the overall safety of industrial EES systems.

In summary, this paper attempts to fill the gaps in existing research on the safety issues of large - scale EES systems, especially in response to the intermittency of renewable energy and the grid - balancing requirements, to ensure the safety and reliability of these systems.