Measuring the Quality of Adult–Child Interactions in the Context of ECEC: a Systematic Review on the Relationship with Developmental and Educational Outcomes

Steven J. Howard,Kate L. Lewis,Emma Walter,Irina Verenikina,Lisa K. Kervin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-023-09832-3
IF: 8.24
2024-01-10
Educational Psychology Review
Abstract:Substantial research has aimed to characterise and measure early childhood education and care (ECEC) quality. However, heterogeneity in measures, methods and contexts across studies has made it difficult to reconcile the inconsistent associations reported between quality dimensions and child outcomes. While there is broad consensus that early interactions and experiences may be most strongly and directly influential to children's developmental progress, attempts to identify aspects of quality interactions that relate most highly to child outcomes have tended to focus on particular measures and/or contexts. The aim of this systematical review was to reconcile the available evidence on associations of dimensions of quality interactions in formal ECEC settings (adult–child interactions and associated context and content) with the outcomes of children aged 3–5 years. Uniquely, this review examined how rates of significance differed by measure, country and study characteristics (e.g. sample, study design, risk of bias) – providing nuanced insights on quality indicators that most reliably account for children's developmental progress. Seven databases were searched for the years 2000–2022, yielding 90 studies reporting 870 associations of interaction quality with various child development and educational outcomes. Results indicated little evidence for global ECEC quality indices (e.g. those integrating process quality indicators with structural elements) relating to child outcomes. The consistency in patterns of association improved for some dimensions of interaction quality (e.g. supporting play), with other dimensions showing low support even when they aligned with the outcome (e.g. instructional support with cognitive-academic outcomes). By providing an overview and reconciliation of evidence on the child-level associations in ECEC quality, across diverse measures and contexts, this review raises important questions of current ECEC quality assumptions and practices.
psychology, educational
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main purpose of this paper is to systematically review and integrate research on the quality of adult-child interactions in Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) environments, and to explore how these interactions affect the development and educational outcomes of children aged 3 to 5 years. Specifically, the research objectives include: 1. **Identify Associations**: Determine the associations between different dimensions of adult-child interactions and child development outcomes. 2. **Consistency Across Studies**: Examine whether the direction of these associations is consistent across different studies, and how this consistency is influenced by study characteristics (e.g., sample, study design, risk of bias, etc.). 3. **Differences Across Dimensions**: Investigate whether there are differences in the above two points across different dimensions of interaction quality. To achieve these objectives, the researchers conducted a literature review, retrieving relevant literature from seven databases between 2000 and 2022, and ultimately included 90 studies for analysis. These studies covered various indicators of interaction quality and different aspects of child development, including cognitive academic outcomes and socio-emotional skills. Overall, this paper aims to reveal, by synthesizing existing evidence, which types of adult-child interactions in ECEC environments most effectively promote child development, and to provide guidance for improving current ECEC quality standards and practices.