Evaluating Trust Management Frameworks for Wireless Sensor Networks

Pranav Gangwani,Alexander Perez-Pons,Himanshu Upadhyay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s24092852

IF: 3.9

2024-04-30

Sensors

Abstract:Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are crucial in various fields including Health Care Monitoring, Battlefield Surveillance, and Smart Agriculture. However, WSNs are susceptible to malicious attacks due to the massive quantity of sensors within them. Hence, there is a demand for a trust evaluation framework within WSNs to function as a secure system, to identify and isolate malicious or faulty sensor nodes. This information can be leveraged by neighboring nodes, to prevent collaboration in tasks like data aggregation and forwarding. While numerous trust frameworks have been suggested in the literature to assess trust scores and examine the reliability of sensors through direct and indirect communications, implementing these trust evaluation criteria is challenging due to the intricate nature of the trust evaluation process and the limited availability of datasets. This research conducts a novel comparative analysis of three trust management models: "Lightweight Trust Management based on Bayesian and Entropy (LTMBE)", "Beta-based Trust and Reputation Evaluation System (BTRES)", and "Lightweight and Dependable Trust System (LDTS)". To assess the practicality of these trust management models, we compare and examine their performance in multiple scenarios. Additionally, we assess and compare how well the trust management approaches perform in response to two significant cyber-attacks. Based on the experimental comparative analysis, it can be inferred that the LTMBE model is optimal for WSN applications emphasizing high energy efficiency, while the BTRES model is most suitable for WSN applications prioritizing critical security measures. The conducted empirical comparative analysis can act as a benchmark for upcoming research on trust evaluation frameworks for WSNs.

engineering, electrical & electronic,instruments & instrumentation,chemistry, analytical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the trust management problem in wireless sensor networks (WSNs). Specifically, the paper focuses on how to establish an effective trust evaluation framework in WSNs to identify and isolate malicious or faulty sensor nodes, thereby improving the security and reliability of the network. Due to a large number of sensor nodes, WSNs are vulnerable to various malicious attacks. Therefore, a trust evaluation mechanism is required to ensure the reliable transmission of data and prevent malicious nodes from participating in critical tasks such as data aggregation and forwarding.

To achieve this goal, the paper conducts a detailed comparative analysis of three trust management models: Light - weight Trust Management Based on Bayesian and Entropy (LTMBE), Beta - distribution - based Trust and Reputation Evaluation System (BTRES), and Light - weight and Dependable Trust System (LDTS). By comparing the performance of these models in different scenarios, especially their performance when facing two common network attacks (i.e., on - off attacks and slander attacks), the paper aims to provide a benchmark for future research on trust evaluation frameworks.

The main contributions of the paper include:
1. A comprehensive comparative analysis of three trust management models (LTMBE, BTRES, and LDTS).
2. Establishment of network configurations and assumptions for unbiased experimental analysis and evaluation of these three models.
3. Experimental evaluation and comparison of the performance of these three models in different scenarios, especially when facing on - off attacks and slander attacks.

Through these efforts, the paper not only evaluates the effectiveness and robustness of existing trust management models but also provides important references and guidance for future research.