Abstract:There are logics where necessity is defined by means of a given identity connective: □φ:=φ≡⊤$${\square\varphi := \varphi\equiv\top}$$ (⊤$${\top}$$ is a tautology). On the other hand, in many standard modal logics the concept of propositional identity (PI) φ≡ψ$${\varphi\equiv\psi}$$ can be defined by strict equivalence (SE) □(φ↔ψ)$${\square(\varphi\leftrightarrow\psi)}$$ . All these approaches to modality involve a principle that we call the Collapse Axiom (CA): “There is only one necessary proposition.” In this paper, we consider a notion of PI which relies on the identity axioms of Suszko’s non-Fregean logic SCI. Then S3 proves to be the smallest Lewis modal system where PI can be defined as SE. We extend S3 to a non-Fregean logic with propositional quantifiers such that necessity and PI are integrated as non-interdefinable concepts. CA is not valid and PI refines SE. Models are expansions of SCI-models. We show that SCI-models are Boolean prealgebras, and vice-versa. This associates non-Fregean logic with research on Hyperintensional Semantics. PI equals SE iff models are Boolean algebras and CA holds. A representation result establishes a connection to Fine’s approach to propositional quantifiers and shows that our theories are conservative extensions of S3–S5, respectively. If we exclude the Barcan formula and a related axiom, then the resulting systems are still complete w.r.t. a simpler denotational semantics.

Some Remarks on Semantics and Expressiveness of the Sentential Calculus with Identity

Denotational Semantics for Modal Systems S3–S5 Extended by Axioms for Propositional Quantifiers and Identity

A Proof-theoretic Semantics for Intuitionistic Linear Logic

Base-extension Semantics for Modal Logic

Ontology and Formal Semantics - Integration Overdue

Categorical Proof-Theoretic Semantics

A Coalgebraic Semantics for Intuitionistic Modal Logic

Intuitionistic logic, dual intuitionistic logic, and modality

A Topos-Theoretic Semantics of Intuitionistic Modal Logic with an Application to the Logic of Branching Spacetime

A unified relational semantics for BPL, IPL and OL -- axiomatization without disjunction

The duality of computation under focus

Possibility Semantics

Suszko's Thesis and Many-valued Logical Structures

Two-dimensional Kripke Semantics II: Stability and Completeness

Syntax-semantics interface: an algebraic model

Categorical Framework for Typed Extensional and Intensional Models in Formal Semantics

Modal Structuralism with Theoretical Terms

Proof-theoretic Semantics for Intuitionistic Multiplicative Linear Logic (Extended Abstract)

Synchronous Games, Simulations and lambda-calculus