"A Fairy Realm of Romance": Revising the Pastoral in Lucy Maud Montgomery's Rainbow Valley and Rilla of Ingleside

Maryam Khorasani
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10583-024-09577-9
2024-04-11
Evolutionary Psychology
Abstract:Although widely recognized for the idyllic depictions of nature in her fiction, L.M. Montgomery's portrayal of the non-human world is more ambivalent than what is primarily suggested in the existing scholarship on her work. This article explores the ways in which Montgomery's representation of nature and its relation to the child in Rainbow Valley and Rilla of Ingleside resists a reading of the two novels as exclusively pastoral. Particularly, I suggest that the disparity between certain characters' emotional state and nature's indifference precludes an overidentification with the landscape, resisting what Val Plumwood refers to as idealized fusion with nature. I will draw on Gerald Prince's concept of metanarration along with Plumwood's concept of hyperseparation to examine the ways in which Montgomery's texts do not erode the difference between the child and nature. Building on the interconnection between ecofeminism and affect theory, I will additionally propose an alternative approach to particular instances of nature personification in Montgomery's work that potentially resists an anthropocentric discourse of sameness in the last two novels in the Anne series.
psychology, experimental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?