Impact of Green Supply Chain Management Practices on the Environmental Performance of Manufacturing Firms Considering Institutional Pressure as a Moderator

Samera Nazir,Li Zhaolei,Saqib Mehmood,Zarish Nazir
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16062278
IF: 3.9
2024-03-09
Sustainability
Abstract:This study aimed to investigate the influence of green supply chain management practices on the environmental performance of manufacturing firms, with a specific focus on understanding how institutional pressure moderated this relationship. The research design encompassed a holistic approach, incorporating an in-depth examination of the current literature and data collection via a well-structured questionnaire. Random sampling was utilized to gather data from manufacturing companies in Pakistan, and the data analysis employed PLS-SEM. The findings revealed a significant relationship between GSCM practices and the environmental performance of manufacturing firms. Moreover, the study identified that institutional pressure played a moderating role, influencing the strength of this relationship. Notably, the impact of GSCM practices on environmental performance varied under different levels of institutional pressure. This research underscored the importance of considering institutional pressure in understanding the link between GSCM practices and environmental performance. The implications extended to academics and practitioners, providing insights into the nuanced dynamics of sustainable practices in manufacturing settings. Practical implications involved tailoring GSCM strategies based on varying degrees of institutional pressure for optimal environmental outcomes. The original contribution of this study lies in its comprehensive exploration of the interplay between GSCM practices, institutional pressure, and environmental performance. By incorporating institutional pressure as a moderator, the research provided a nuanced understanding of how external influences shaped the effectiveness of GSCM in fostering ecological sustainability within manufacturing firms.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to study the impact of Green Supply Chain Management (GSCM) practices on the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises, with a particular focus on the moderating role of institutional pressure in this relationship. Specifically: 1. **Research Objectives**: - Determine the relationship between green supply chain planning and the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. - Determine the relationship between green procurement and the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. - Determine the relationship between green supply chain execution and the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. - Determine the relationship between green supply chain migration and the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. - Determine the relationship between green supply chain continuous improvement and the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. - Explore how institutional pressure moderates the relationship between GSCM and the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. 2. **Research Background**: - The paper points out how manufacturing enterprises in Pakistan, when facing institutional pressure, improve their environmental performance by implementing GSCM practices. Institutional theory suggests that institutional pressures (including normative, mimetic, and coercive pressures) influence the relationship between GSCM practices and environmental performance. - The stronger the institutional pressure, the more significant the improvement in environmental performance. For example, strict environmental regulations and strong societal expectations for sustainability will prompt enterprises to better adopt and implement GSCM practices. 3. **Main Contributions**: - By integrating the Resource-Based View (RBV), Triple Bottom Line (TBL), and institutional theory, the paper reveals how institutional pressure moderates the utilization of resources and strategic decisions of enterprises, thereby enhancing environmental performance. - Provides practical guidance to help enterprises formulate sustainable development strategies, optimize resource utilization, and enhance competitiveness. - Fills the research gap regarding environmental activities in Pakistan's manufacturing sector and provides evidence-based recommendations for policymakers. ### Specific Hypotheses 1. **H1**: Green supply chain planning is positively correlated with the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. 2. **H2**: Green procurement is positively correlated with the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. 3. **H3**: Green supply chain execution is positively correlated with the environmental performance of manufacturing enterprises. ### Summary Through an empirical study of manufacturing enterprises in Pakistan, this paper explores the effects of GSCM practices under different institutional pressures and proposes a series of hypotheses, aiming to provide in-depth insights into sustainable development for both academia and practice.