Effects of Parallel Contact Cooling on Pulsed-Type, Bipolar Radiofrequency-Induced Tissue Reactions in an in vivo Porcine Model
Sung Bin Cho,Yea-Jin Lee,Sun Young Kang,Min Choi,Bora Kim,Jin-Chul Ahn
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ccid.s446814
2024-01-19
Clinical Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology
Abstract:Sung Bin Cho, 1, &ast Yea-Jin Lee, 2, &ast Sun Young Kang, 3 Min Choi, 3 Bora Kim, 3 Jin-Chul Ahn 2 1 Yonsei Seran Dermatology and Laser Clinic, Seoul, Korea; 2 Medical Laser Research Center, College of Medicine, Dankook University, Cheonan, Korea; 3 R&D Center, Shenb Co., Ltd, Seoul, Korea &astThese authors contributed equally to this work Correspondence: Jin-Chul Ahn, Medical Laser Research Center, College of Medicine, Dankook University, Cheonan, 31116, Korea, Tel +82.41-550-1811, Fax +82.41-550-7706, Email Background: Skin cooling during laser or radiofrequency (RF) treatments is a method to minimize thermal damage to the epidermis, reduce pain, and decrease post-treatment downtime. We evaluated the effect of parallel contact cooling (PCC) on RF-induced thermal reactions in minipig skin in vivo after bipolar microneedling RF treatment. Methods: RF treatments were administered at frequencies of 0.5, 1, and 2 MHz with single (500 ms), six (1000 ms), and ten (5000 ms) sub-pulse packs to minipig skin with or without PCC. Subsequently, thermometric imaging and histology were used to analyze skin reactions to RF. Results: Thermometric images showed that PCC promptly lowered skin temperature in the RF-treated area, with this effect persisting for over 60s. Regardless of the PCC, RF treatments lasting for 500 ms with a single pulse pack resulted in peri-electrode coagulative necrosis (PECN) zones and inter-electrode non-necrotic thermal reaction (IENT) zones in the dermis. In contrast, treatment lasting 5000 ms with 10 sub-pulse packs produced distinct IENT without notable PECN over a wide dermal area. Skin specimens obtained at 1 h and 3, 7, and 14 days after PCC-assisted RF treatments showed a higher degree of thermal tissue reactions in the deeper dermal regions compared to those after RF treatments without PCC. Conclusion: PCC-assisted RF treatment, utilizing an invasive bipolar microneedling device, enhanced RF-induced skin reactions in the mid to deep dermis while preserving the epidermis and upper papillary dermis from excessive thermal tissue injury. Keywords: radiofrequency, parallel contact cooling, thermoelectric cooling, bipolar, alternating current, gated pulse, tissue reaction, porcine model Bipolar, alternating current, microneedling radiofrequency (RF) devices have been used in the treatment of various dermatological disorders. 1–4 RF treatments, administered through insulated or non-insulated microneedle electrodes, can take the form of a single pulse pack or multiple sub-pulse packs. 5–7 RF treatment generates different patterns of thermal tissue reactions, influenced by several parameters, including RF frequency, power, conduction time, number of sub-pulse packs, on-time of each sub-pulse pack, off-time between sub-pulse packs, and the type of microneedles used. 5–7 RF treatment is known to induce various tissue reactions, including non-necrotic thermal reactions with reversible cell damage at temperatures of 40–45 °C, coagulation necrosis at temperatures exceeding 60 °C, and tissue desiccation above 100 °C. 1,8 However, the specific treatment parameters that induce RF-induced thermal reactions have not been fully elucidated. In a recent in vivo study on rat skin, we described the thermal tissue reactions resulting from 1-MHz RF treatments with insulated microneedle electrodes. Specifically, we focused on peri-electrode and inter-electrode areas in the dermis under varying conduction times and numbers of sub-pulse packs. 5 We observed that increasing the total RF conduction time from 200 to 800 ms under a single pulse pack setting led to an expansion of peri-electrode coagulation necrosis (PECN), which was histologically presented as a relatively well-demarcated round to oval-shaped zone of tissue coagulation along the penetrating electrode. 5 The location and degree of coagulation necrosis were influenced by skin tissue impedance and adjacent adnexal structures. Conversely, under multiple sub-pulse pack settings, increasing the number of sub-pulse packs reduced or eliminated the PECN zone. 5 Interestingly, with extended off-time settings between sub-pulse packs, we observed a more distinct inter-electrode non-necrotic thermal reaction (IENT) zone in the upper papillary, mid, deep dermis, and subcutaneous fat layers. Therein, IENT was histologically presented as a relatively ill-demarcated zone of eosinophilic cellular and stromal changes between the penetrating electrodes without remarkable tissue necrosis. This effect was more prominent when using seven or ten sub-pulse packs, despite a significantly sh -Abstract Truncated-
dermatology