Abstract:Background People with mental illness are overrepresented in United States (US) criminal legal systems. In response, alternatives to traditional police response to behavioral health emergencies have become more common, despite limited evidence for their effectiveness. We conducted the first randomized controlled trial of a police-mental health co-response team to determine program effectiveness relative to a police-as-usual response on key outcomes identified by community stakeholders. Methods Between January 2020 and March 2021, we randomized behavioral health emergency calls for service in one of six police districts in Indianapolis, Indiana to receive a co-response or police-as-usual response during operational hours between 10 a.m. and 5 p.m. Mondays – Fridays. Eligible calls for service were determined via pre-specified phrases indicating a behavioral health incident over the police dispatch radio. Researchers then communicated random assignment with the co-response team to indicate whether they should respond or withhold. Logistic and negative binomial regression were used to assess group differences in emergency medical services (EMS) events within 12 months of the randomized incident along with jail booking, outpatient encounters, and emergency department visits. Findings We randomized 686 calls for service with co-response completed in 264 cases and police-as-usual response in 267 cases. The overall rate of attrition was similar across conditions and the final sample included 211 co-responses and 224 police-as-usual responses. We found no significant differences in any EMS event (odds ratio [OR]: 1.26; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.85–1.88, p = .246) or event counts (incidence rate ratio [IRR]: 0.85; 95% CI: 0.52–1.37, p = .504). We also found no differences in secondary outcomes (jail booking, outpatient encounters, and emergency department visits). Discussion A police-mental health co-response team model was not more effective than traditional police response on key outcomes. Co-response team models, such as the one reported here, may unintentionally foster emergency services utilization among persons with behavioral health needs. Without a functioning national mental health system, communities in the US will continue to struggle to identify solutions to meet the needs of community members with complex behavioral health issues.

"Meshing into One": An Assessment of Law Enforcement and Clinician Perspectives on Professional Roles and the Embedded Co-Responder Model

ARRIVE Together: A Qualitative Process Evaluation of the New Jersey State Police Co-responding Pilot Program

Police-mental health co-response versus police-as-usual response to behavioral health emergencies: A pragmatic randomized effectiveness trial

Community-Based Mental Health Crisis Response: An Overview of Models and Workforce Implications

Matching Mobile Crisis Models to Communities: An Example from Northwestern Ontario

A national train-the-trainer program to enhance police response to veterans with mental health issues: Primary officer and trainer outcomes and material dissemination.

"So Just with every Facet, Every Side of this Journey, They Have Somebody Walking alongside with Them": Practitioners' Perspectives of the Lethality Assessment Program as a Collaborative Model

Incorporating Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) Knowledge and Skills into the Daily Work of Police Officers: A Focus Group Study

Contradictions Between Community-Oriented Police Training and Paramilitary Police Training: Implications for Police Recruit Mental Health Response Training

The 2nd Alarm Project: Bridging Social Work and Public Health to Improve Mental Wellness in the Fire Service

The Who, What, and How of Interagency Criminal Justice–Behavioral Health Teams: Developing and Sustaining Collaborations

Restructuring Law Enforcement Agencies to Support Prosocial Values: A Behavior-Scientific Model for Addressing Police Brutality

Insights from Developing and Implementing a Novel School Community Collaborative Model to Promote School Safety

Responding to Childhood Trauma: Developing and Learning from Collaborations Beyond the Consulting Room

Exploring the Delivery of Healthcare in the Police Detention Center Through Remote Presence Technology

Police social work and community policing

Animal Protection, Law Enforcement, and Occupational Health: Qualitative Action Research Highlights the Urgency of Relational Coordination in a Medico-Legal Borderland

Shifting the Service Referral Paradigm Using Community-Based Second Responders: Examining Weapon Use in Intimate Partner Violence

Despondent officer narratives and the ‘post-Ferguson’ effect: exploring law enforcement perspectives and strategies in a southern American state

Police Stress and Deleterious Outcomes: Efforts Towards Improving Police Mental Health

Police Resilience as a Multilevel Balance: Needs and Resources for Victim Support Officers