Abstract:Background: Aphasia language therapy sessions have a general “order of phases” and usually open with a period of casual conversation. It has been noted that the overall structure of participation in therapy, characterised by therapist control, is anticipated in this opening phase. The detailed mechanisms through which control is achieved and sustained have not been fully examined. The processes through which these mechanisms operate and their relationship with participant roles and identities appear to be especially relevant for study if the overall goal of aphasia therapy is to address life participation and the social context of communication (e.g., Shadden & Agan, 2004). Aims: The concern of this paper is to examine in detail some of the mechanisms through which professional control is achieved and sustained, with a particular focus on ways in which speech and language therapists and people with aphasia work at generating and maintaining the topics that are observed to develop in the opening phase of aphasia language therapy sessions. In addition, there is a specific interest in how, in certain instances, the activity of topic generation and maintenance may be shown to relate to the participants' identities as “professional” and “patient”. Methods & Procedures: The paper focuses on analysis of data from the opening phase of five sessions, one each from three therapist/person with aphasia dyads, and two from separate sessions of a fourth dyad. Data from these sessions are taken from a larger study of aphasia language therapy in day‐to‐day practice. The turn‐by‐turn process of topic generation is examined in detail using techniques from Conversation Analysis in conjunction with a consideration of “membership categorisation” and “category‐bounded activities”. Outcomes & Results: Close examination of the process of topic generation and maintenance in five sessions from four different dyads revealed how therapists selected certain topics for topicalisation and rejected others. Selected topics were related to activities closely tied to the person with aphasia's identity as a person with communication impairment. In so doing the therapists established a particular type of therapeutic identity for themselves. Conclusions: Managing the person with aphasia's identity by addressing communication activities that are bound to the aphasic impairment and rejecting other types may, perversely, hamper a speech and language therapist's understanding of that person with aphasia's communicative competence, including broader issues that may be germane to intervention. Understanding and recognising where control resides and through which mechanisms it operates is of potential benefit to therapists and people with aphasia alike—for example, enabling more focused and realistic goal setting or more accurate insights into the impact of aphasia, and aphasia language therapy on everyday social participation. The challenge for therapists and for people with aphasia is to be able to shift roles appropriately and act as equals in the enterprise of therapy.

Therapy as identity leadership: Commentary on "Robertson et al. (2023): A social identity approach to facilitating therapy groups".

Cultivating cultural consciousness: Identity-based affinity groups among clinical trainees.

This is not just a commentary on evidence-based group therapy research: It is important to the future of psychotherapy practice.

Mentalizing, Attachment, and Epistemic Trust in Group Therapy

A review of social identity theory with implications for training and development

Topic generation in aphasia language therapy sessions: Issues of identity

A social identity approach to crisis leadership

New horizons in group psychotherapy research and practice from third wave positive psychology: a practice-friendly review

Learning and Living Systemic: Exploring the Personal Effects of Family Therapy Training

Identity Leadership in a Crisis: A 5R Framework for Learning from Responses to COVID‐19

Schizophrenia, the self and psychotherapy: Is there really anything new under the sun?

Understanding and Improving Athlete Mental Health: A Social Identity Approach

Leading by Example: Identity Leadership and Mental Health in Men's Sheds Members

Expanding the Lens: How SERT Therapists Develop Interventions that Address the Larger Context

Patients' Perspective on the Important Therapeutic Factors in Integrated Systemic Group Therapy: A Phenomenological Approach

Group processes in medical education: learning from social identity theory

A Social Identity Approach to Sport Psychology: Principles, Practice, and Prospects

Supporting Identity Development in Talented Youth Athletes: Insights from Existential and Cultural Psychological Approaches

The social psychology of responses to trauma: social identity pathways associated with divergent traumatic responses

From Agency to Responsibility: Gestalt Therapy Trainees' Experience of Engaging in Personal Therapy

The Analytic Institute as a Psychic Retreat: Why We Need to Include Research Evidence in Our Clinical Training