The effectiveness of instructor feedback for learning-oriented language assessment: Using an integrated reading-to-write task for English for academic purposes

Ah-Young Kim,Hyun Jung Kim,Ah-Young (Alicia) Kim
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asw.2016.12.001
IF: 3.9
2017-04-01
Assessing Writing
Abstract:Learning-oriented language assessment (LOLA) can be effective in promoting learning through assessment by creating a link between the two. Although previous studies have examined the effectiveness of feedback – a major element of LOLA – in L2 writing, few have examined how LOLA could be implemented using an integrated reading-to-write task in English for academic purpose (EAP) contexts, which was the objective of this study.Participants were ten Korean TESOL graduate students taking a research methods course and their professor. During a seven-week period, each student completed a weekly integrated reading-to-write task as part of their classroom assessment – they read an academic research paper on a topic of their choice and wrote a review on it. After receiving feedback from the instructor, students revised their work and resubmitted it the following week. Students and the instructor also participated in a semi-structured interview to discuss the effectiveness of learning-oriented feedback on academic reading-to-write tasks.Learners displayed varying developmental patterns, with some students showing more improvement than others. The findings highlighted two participants’ progress in the content domain. Qualitative analysis results suggest that the students reacted differently to the instructor feedback, leading to varying degrees of writing enhancement. The results provide pedagogical implications for using integrated academic reading-to-write tasks and sustained feedback for LOLA.
education & educational research,linguistics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?