Reliability of OMERACT ultrasound elementary lesions in gout: results from a multicenter exercise
Tomas Cazenave,Victoria Martire,Anthony M. Reginato,Marwin Gutierrez,Christian Alfredo Waimann,Carlos Pineda,Javier Eduardo Rosa,Santiago Ruta,Oscar Sedano-Santiago,Ana Maria Bertoli,Marcelo Audisio,Cristina Hernandez-Diaz,Lucio Ventura-Rios,Maritza Quintero,Eugenio De Miguel,Ana Laura Alvarez-del-Castillo-Araujo,Andy Abril,Eliana Natalí Ayala-Ledesma,Edith Alarcon-Isidro,Maria Lida Santiago,Mariana Alejandra Pera,Cecilia Urquiola,Gustavo Rodriguez Gil,Lina Maria Saldarriaga Rivera,Cesar Cefferino,Mariana Benegas,Mario Enrique Diaz Cortes,Maximiliano Bravo,Diana Peiteado,Natalia Anahi Estrella,Roser Areny Micas,Jorge Saavedra Muñoz,Rodolfo del Carmen Arape Toyo,Maria Soledad Gálvez Elkin,Walter Javier Spindler,Clarisa Sandobal,Josefina Marin,Manuella Lima Gomes Ochtrop,Ricardo Pavao Ayala,Erika Roxana Catay,Guillermo Enrique Py,Gabriel Hector Aguilar,Yvonne Yona Rengel Colina,Carla Antonela Airoldi,Claudia Selene Mora-Trujillo,Maria Paula Kohan,Lorena Evelin Urioste Eguez,Concepción Castillo-Gallego,Jose Francisco Diaz-Coto,Patricio Tate,Carla Magali Saucedo,Oscar Vega-Hinojosa,Cristian Jonatan Troitiño,Maria Florencia Marengo,Priscila Maria Marcaida,Irene Monjo Henry,Roberto Muñoz-Louis,Carla Solano,Felix Reinaldo Fernandez Castillo,Cesar Enrique Graf,Mara Guinsburg,Maria Julia Santa Cruz,David Alejandro Navarta Ortiz,Magaly Alva Linares,Marcos Gabriel Rosemffet,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00296-018-4220-0
2018-12-11
Rheumatology International
Abstract:The aim of this study was to evaluate the reliability of the outcome measures in rheumatology (OMERACT) definitions for ultrasound (US) elementary lesions in gout through an image reading exercise. Images from patients with gout (static images and videos) were collected. As an initial step, we carried out a image reading exercise within the experts of the Pan-American League of Associations for Rheumatology (PANLAR) US Study Group (n = 16). The following step consisted in a web-based exercise with the participation of larger number of sonographers (n = 63) from different centers. Images were rated evaluating the presence/absence of any US elementary lesion. Inter- and intra-reader reliabilities were analyzed using kappa coefficients. Participants were stratified according to their level of experience. In the first exercise, inter-reader kappa values were 0.45 for aggregates, 0.57 for tophus, 0.69 for erosions, and 0.90 for double contour (DC). Intra-reader kappa values were 0.86, 0.76, 0.80, and 0.90, respectively. The web-based exercise showed inter-reader kappa values for aggregates, tophus, erosions, and DC of 0.42, 0.49, 0.69, and 0.79, respectively. The intra-reader kappa values were 0.62, 0.69, 0.77, and 0.85, respectively. Reliability was not influenced by the sonographer’s level of experience. The reliability of the new OMERACT US definitions for elementary lesions in gout ranged from moderate to excellent, depending on the type of lesion.
rheumatology