Influence of site of expression on the fetal yv T-cell receptor repertoire
S. Kyes,W. Pao,A. Hayday
Abstract:The sequences of productive T-cell y/6 receptor transcripts were compared in different murine fetal tissues. Differences from tissue to tissue suggest that the sequence repertoires are at least in part the products of selection, presumably through interaction ofT cells bearing the yv receptor with fetal self-ligands. Theoretically, the outcome of a differentiation program can be limited "mechanistically," reflecting restricted differentiation potential of a precursor cell, and "selectively," reflecting the dominant influence on the program of heterogeneous cells at the site of differentiation. The degree to which mechanism and selection influence differentiation is a major issue in vertebrate developmental biology. For lymphocytes that will bear the T-cell receptor composed of a and ( chains (afB TCR), it has been established that interactions of immature cells with stromal cells of the thymus in large part select which thymocytes will be exported to the peripheral immune system as mature T cells (1-6). T cells bearing the ah TCR (a/3 T cells) recognize polymorphic ligands-hence, the utility ofa system that selects for maturation ofthymocytes with appropriate ligand-binding specificities. However, the generality of such a system is unclear. T cells that bear the Vy TCR (y6T cells) also develop substantially (although seemingly not uniquely) in the thymus (7). It is not clear, however, what Vy T cells generally recognize in vivo. Nor is it clear that the Vy TCR repertoire is ordinarily a product of selection. To examine this, we have compared the yV TCR repertoires in different fetal tissues directly ex vivo. We reasoned that if the repertoire diversity is the same in all tissues, it is presumably a product of mechanistically restricted stem cell capability, whereas if the repertoires are different in different tissues, then they are at least in part results of interactions at different sites-that is to say, tissue-specific selection events. MATERIALS AND METHODS Mice. C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice were obtained from The Jackson Laboratory and bred in the Yale University Animal Facility. Fetal mice were staged, and tissues were prepared as described (7). All experiments with animals were carried out in American Association for the Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care-accredited facilities under a protocol awarded to A.H. by the Yale Use of Animals Committee. cDNA. Sequences were derived after polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of specific mRNA, as described in our previous analyses (7, 8). In this study, the RNA was harvested in each case from dissected tissues of complete prenatal or immediately postnatal litters. Each RNA preparation was checked for its integrity by gel electrophoresis and staining (by a modification of the formaldehyde gel technique that is applicable to 1-S.g samples of total RNA) and by the capacity of the cDNA corresponding to the RNA to efficiently amplify j-tubulin gene fragments between 3-tubulin primers (7). Intact RNA samples from two or three independent litters were then pooled to provide the substrate for reverse transcription and amplification. Pooling avoids skewing of the data by properties unique to one mouse or one mouse litter. Gut, liver, and thymus were sampled from mice of the same litters. PCR. Amplification was attempted between variable gene (V) segment primers and constant gene (C) segment primers. In this way, all rearrangements to a particular Vgene segment could be detected and compared, irrespective ofthe diversity gene (D) and joining (J) segments recombined to the V. This was especially relevant for the 6-chain gene analyses (see Table 2). The primers were: V.5, GAGGATCCCGCTTGGAAATGGATGAGA; CY1, (i) AAATTGTCTGCATCAAGTCT and (ii) CCACCACTCGTTTC[TTAGG; V1,8, TTTAGTATACAAGCTAAATAGC; and C8, (i) AGGGTAGAAATCTTTCACCAGACA and (ii) CTCATGTCAGCCCACCTTAA. For each V, two sets of amplifications were made with different C segment primers to confirm by further means the authenticity of the products detected. Sequence Analysis. PCR products were cloned into pGemini vectors (Stratagene). All y/3 (+) recombinant clones from a transformation experiment were sequenced, except for those that arose on plates very close to one another and therefore were potentially cross-contaminated. For each repertoire, clones were sequenced from more than one ligation experiment. Entire insert sequences were determined by using flanking and internal primers to drive dideoxynucleotide reactions, as described before (8). The sequence repertoires were compared one with another statistically by using the Wilcoxon two-sample rank test, with adjustment for tied scores. This test is appropriate because it allows determination of the probability of a null hypothesis that two samples are derived from the same population, without making a hypothesis a priori about the nature of the population. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Murine V Y5--CY1/V1--C8 is the predominant TCR expressed early in fetal thymic development (9, 10). The y chains are encoded by an essentially monomorphic rearrangement of Vr5-Jyl (10). The junction is a simple one (Table 1), with no N region nucleotide contribution. This is characteristic of "fetal-type" joins formed early in ontogeny (10, 12, 13). The recurrent y-chain gene rearrangement is termed the "canonical" y sequence. There is likewise a canonical fetal-type VsJ-D,2-J42 rearrangement (Table 2, sequence 1). Fetal thymocytes that express Vy5-Vsl chains can give rise to peripheral dendritic epithelial cells (DECs) of postnatal skin (14). DEC populations have essentially the same fetal-type Vy Abbreviations: TCR, T-cell receptor; a/,8 or y/8 TCR, TCR composed of a and (3 or y and 8 chains; y8T cell, T cell bearing yv TCR; DEC, dendritic epithelial cell; V, variable; C, constant; D, diversity; J, joining. 7830 The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88 (1991) 7831 Table 1. DNA sequences of germ-line and rearranged murine Vy5-JyI genes at the junctions of the two gene segments