Abstract:This paper investigates agents’ simultaneous learning about multiple interacting technologies in the context of fertilizer application in China. We first present experimental evidence that farmers overuse nitrogen fertilizers and underuse phosphorus and potassium fertilizers, relative to the personalized fertilizer recommendations based on plot-level soil analysis. Our first-phase intervention that provides customized fertilizer recommendations leads to reduced nitrogen applications and increased phosphorus/potassium uses. Average yields and revenues are 5-7% higher, while total fertilizer costs remain unchanged. These results are also consistent with a meaningful reduction in greenhouse gas (N2O) emissions linked to nitrogen overuse. Survey data suggest that farmers overestimate the return to nitrogen because it produces a salient signal on crops by increasing greenness, but they underestimate the effectiveness of phosphorus and potassium because their effects are barely observable during the growing stages. Motivated by these facts, we then propose a model of misspecified learning in which agents face two technologies with unknown returns. In learning about the effectiveness of both technologies, the overestimation of the return to the first technology causes an undervaluation and underuse of the second technology. To further test the model, we design a second-phase intervention that distributes leaf color charts to farmers to correct their overestimation of the return to greenness. Consistent with the model prediction, the intervention not only reduces farmers’ nitrogen use immediately, but also induces gradual learning of phosphorus and potassium; the proportion of farmers using phosphorus and potassium both increase by 6 percentage points, relative to 4% and 9% in the control group.

Misattribution prevents learning

Learning with misattribution of reference dependence

The Sin of Prediction: When Mentally Simulated Alternatives Compete With Reality

How Do Expectations Affect Learning About Fundamentals? Some Experimental Evidence

Misspecified Learning in Technology Adoption: Experimental Evidence from Fertilizer Use in China

Why Don'T We Learn from Poor Choices? the Consistency of Expectation, Choice, and Memory Clouds the Lessons of Experience

The "curse of knowledge" when predicting others' knowledge

Should Knowledge Be Distorted? Managers' Knowledge Distortion Strategies and Organizational Learning in Different Environments

Misinformation Due to Asymmetric Information Sharing

The Effect of Learning on Ambiguity Attitudes

Misspecified Beliefs about Time Lags

Overinference from Weak Signals and Underinference from Strong Signals

Endogenous Barriers to Learning

Biased Learning Creates Overconfidence

Simple learning models can illuminate biased results from choice titration experiments

This is What’s in Store for You: How Online Social Learning Affects Product Positioning

How to overcome algorithm aversion: Learning from mistakes

Consumer Behavior Under Conflicting Information Provided by Interested Parties: Implications for Equilibrium in the Market for Credence Goods

Motivated Errors

Price discrimination with consumer misperception