The Kocher–Caird Criteria for Pediatric Septic Arthritis of the Hip: Time for a Change in the Kingella Era?

Silvia Valisena,Giacomo De Marco,Oscar Vazquez,Blaise Cochard,Christina Steiger,Romain Dayer,Dimitri Ceroni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms12030550

IF: 4.5

2024-03-10

Microorganisms

Abstract:Pediatric septic arthritis of the hip (SAH) in children is a severe pathology, requiring prompt diagnosis and treatment to avoid destructive sequelae of the joint. Its diagnosis can be challenging, however, due to its spectrum of manifestations and differential diagnosis. Last century, multiple research teams studied the curves of systemic inflammation markers to aid the differential diagnosis. Kocher showed that a history of fever >38.5 °C, non-weight bearing, an erythrocyte sedimentation rate >40 mm/h, and serum white blood cells >12,000/mm3 were highly suggestive of SAH, with a predicted probability of 99.6% when all these predictors manifested in pediatric patients. Caird validated these criteria, also adding a C-reactive protein >20 mg/L, reaching a 98% probability of SAH when these five criteria were present. The Kocher and the Caird criteria were then applied in multiple settings, but were never clearly validated. Moreover, they were studied and validated in the years when Kingella kingae was just emerging, and this was probably responsible for false-negative cases in multiple centers. For this reason, the Kocher and the Caird criteria are still at the center of a debate on the diagnostic tools for pediatric SAH. We provide a historical overview of the development of clinical and laboratory test algorithms for pediatric SAH. Further, new perspectives for future research on the prediction rules of pediatric SAH are here proposed.

microbiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the diagnostic challenges of Septic Arthritis of the Hip (SAH) in children and whether existing predictive rules are still applicable, especially in the context of the increasing incidence of Kingella kingae infections.

The paper first introduces that Septic Arthritis of the Hip in children is a serious condition that requires timely diagnosis and treatment to avoid severe consequences such as joint destruction. However, diagnosing this disease is challenging because its symptoms are diverse and similar to other non-infectious conditions, such as Transient Synovitis of the Hip (TSH).

Next, the paper reviews the historical development of predictive rules for distinguishing septic arthritis from transient synovitis of the hip. Among them, Kocher et al. proposed a set of predictive rules in 1999, suggesting that the likelihood of septic arthritis is as high as 99.6% when the following four indicators are present: fever over 38.5°C, inability to bear weight, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) greater than 40 mm/hour, and serum white blood cell count exceeding 12,000/mm³. Subsequently, Caird et al. in 2006 further validated these criteria and added C-reactive protein (CRP) greater than 20 mg/L as a fifth indicator, increasing the predictive probability to 97%.

However, these predictive rules were proposed in an era when Kingella kingae was not a major pathogen. As the proportion of hip infections caused by Kingella kingae gradually increases, these predictive rules have begun to show limitations. Kingella kingae infections usually present with milder symptoms, causing some patients to not meet multiple indicators in the predictive rules, leading to false-negative results. For example, an Israel-Spain study found that 71% of Kingella kingae-related septic arthritis patients met only two or fewer of the Kocher criteria, meaning they were more likely to be classified as low risk.

In summary, the paper attempts to address whether the existing Kocher-Caird predictive rules are still applicable for diagnosing Septic Arthritis of the Hip in children in the current era of Kingella kingae, especially considering the characteristics of Kingella kingae infections. The article emphasizes the need for new predictive rules to better guide clinical practice, particularly when dealing with Kingella kingae infections.