Economic Impact of Lean Healthcare Implementation on the Surgical Process

Marc Sales Coll,Rodolfo De Castro,Anna Ochoa de Echagüen,Vicenç Martínez Ibáñez
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/healthcare12050512
2024-02-22
Health Care
Abstract:Objectives: The objective of this study was to analyse and detail surgical process improvement activities that achieve the highest economic impact. Methods: Over 4 years, a team of technicians and healthcare professionals implemented a set of Lean surgical process improvement projects at Vall d'Hebron University Hospital (VHUH), Barcelona, Spain. Methods employed in the study are common in manufacturing environments and include reducing waiting and changeover time (SMED), reducing first time through, pull, and continuous flow. Projects based on these methods now form part of the daily routine in the surgical process. The economic impact on the hospital's surgical activity budget was analysed. Results: Process improvements have led to annual operational savings of over EUR 8.5 million. These improvements include better patient flow, better management of information between healthcare professionals, and improved logistic circuits. Conclusions: The current cultural shift towards process management in large hospitals implies shifting towards results-based healthcare, patient-perceived value (VBHC), and value-added payment. A Lean project implementation process requires long-term stability. The reason a considerable number of projects fail to complete process improvement projects is the difficulty involved in establishing the project and improving management routines. Few studies in the literature have investigated the economic impact of implementing Lean management a posteriori, and even fewer have examined actual cases. In this real case study, changes to surgical block management were initiated from stage zero. After being carefully thought through and designed, changes were carried out and subsequently analysed.
health care sciences & services,health policy & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the economic impact of Lean Healthcare in the improvement of surgical processes. The objective of the study is to analyze and describe in detail those surgical process improvement activities that can generate the greatest economic benefits. The research methodology of the paper includes the implementation of a series of lean surgical process improvement projects at Vall d’Hebron University Hospital (VHUH) in Barcelona, Spain. These projects employed common methods from the lean production environment, such as reducing waiting times and Single Minute Exchange of Die (SMED), first-pass yield, pull systems, and continuous flow production. These projects have become part of the hospital's routine surgical processes and have had an economic impact on the hospital's surgical activity budget. The study results indicate that process improvements save the hospital over €8.5 million annually. These improvements include optimizing patient flow, enhancing information exchange among healthcare staff, and improving logistics routes. The conclusion section emphasizes the importance of large hospitals transitioning to a process management culture, which promotes outcome-based healthcare services, Value-Based Healthcare (VBHC), and value-added payment models. Additionally, the paper points out that although the implementation of lean projects requires long-term stable support, many projects fail due to difficulties in establishing and improving management routines. In summary, this paper, through the study of actual cases, demonstrates the economic effects of lean management in surgical process improvement and proposes specific improvement metrics to evaluate the effectiveness of these measures. This is valuable for other healthcare institutions that wish to adopt similar methods to improve efficiency and service quality.