The effect of the Internet on service trade

Changkyu Choi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2010.08.005

IF: 1.469

2010-11-01

Economics Letters

Abstract:A doubling of Internet usage in a country turned out to lead to a 2 to 4% increase in services trade. An increase in a country's Internet access will facilitate an increase in its service trade with other countries.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Does the Development of the Internet Improve the Allocative Efficiency of Production Factors? Evidence from Surveys of Chinese Manufacturing Firms

Yajie Liu,Lijuan Cui,Yanyan Xiong,Xianguo Yao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.strueco.2023.04.017

IF: 5.059

2023-01-01

Structural Change and Economic Dynamics

Abstract:Using data from the Annual Survey of Industrial Firms conducted from 1998 to 2013 in China, this study examines whether the expansion of the Internet improves the allocative efficiency of production factors in manufacturing industry. Allocative efficiency is measured by the deviation of the actual output from the hypothetical efficient output level. We construct an instrumental variable based on historical data to address potential endogeneity. The results highlight that the Internet improves capital and labour allocative efficiency and has heterogeneous effects in different industries. The effect is larger in low-technology industries. As a technology augmenting production factor, the Internet significantly improves the allocative efficiency of capital (labour) in the industries that use capital (labour) intensively. The mechanism analysis reveals that the Internet improves the allocative efficiency of firms by reducing their overhead expenses and raising the exit rate of inefficient firms from the market. This study extends the research on the effect of Internet and explores the causal relationship between the Internet and the allocative efficiency within industries, to highlight the importance of digital technology in economic growth, especially in the context of developing countries.
A Study on the Effect of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) on Trade in Services in the United States

Myeongjoo Kang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.58346/jisis.2024.i1.017

2024-03-02

Abstract:The pandemic of COVID-19 appears to boost trade in services and even the ICT service exports in the U.S. The U.S. has been recognized as the world's largest services market and became a leading exporter and importer of services over the last two decades. In this perspective, this study attempts to empirically identify the impact of ICT on trade in services and ICT service exports in the U.S. by employing the modified gravity model of trade from 1990 to 2021. The results indicate that overall ICT access and ICT use have significant positive effects on the trade in services and ICT service exports, but others brought about different results. The study also finds two important facts. First, FTS has a positive effect on the trade in services and ICT services exports, while, MCS has a completely negative effect on both the trade in services and ICT services exports. More interestingly, the dimension of ICT use of IUI and FBS have a different impact on both trade in services and ICT services exports. Another important finding is that the coefficients of IUI and FBS in relation to the trade in services have an unexpected negative sign, while both IUI and FBS have a positive influence on ICT service exports. Finally, these empirical results imply that ICT use has played a more productive role in enhancing ICT service exports than that of ICT access in the U.S. Consequently, these results might provide vital policy insights for the development of ICT and more rapid growth of services trade.
Impact of Digital Service Trade Barriers and Cross-Border Digital Service Inputs on Economic Growth

Shuang Hao,Zhi Chen,Chien-Chih Wang,Che-Yu Hung

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su151914547

IF: 3.9

2023-10-08

Sustainability

Abstract:In this digital era, digital service trade has brought significant benefits to the global economy. However, this trade also poses considerable challenges to international trade regulations. This study aims to analyze the impact of cross-border digital service trade on the economic growth of importing countries while determining how digital trade barriers moderate this effect. We established a theoretical model that meticulously delineates various restrictive regulatory measures that can hinder digital service inputs. We further developed a comprehensive and detailed trade barrier index based on these measures. A three-dimensional fixed effects panel regression model was used to analyze data from six types of digital services in 48 economies from 2005 to 2021. The findings indicated that cross-border digital service inputs enhance importing countries' economic growth, highlighting the substantial economic value of these inputs. However, trade barriers in digital services were also found to diminish this positive effect. Specifically, an increase in the digital service trade barriers in importing countries constricts the range and quality of selectable digital services, which might adversely impact national economic growth. The inhibitory effect is stronger for countries with a "Limited Model" for personal data transfers and processing.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
The Effect of Online Search on International Trade

Shuzhong Ma,Chao Fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2021.1922593

IF: 1.916

2021-01-01

Applied Economics

Abstract:In the literature, search engines are considered as effective tools for obtaining information. However, little attention has been paid to the effect of search engines on international trade even though information (barrier) is very important in international trade. To address this issue, we analyse how online search, proxied by Google Trends Interest by Region (GTIR), affects international trade in a classic gravity model. Our results show that online search intensity between the two countries can significantly promote international trade. This finding is robust to a wide range of tests, including instrumental variable estimation, different specifications and different estimators. Mechanism analysis shows that online search is likely to increase trade by overcoming unfamiliarity and reducing trade risks. Since the role of online search is similar to that of traditional networks, we further conduct extended analysis and find that online search is likely to substitute, rather than complement, migration networks in international trade. Since many traditional networks are broken due to the pandemic, online search is promising to become increasingly important in the future.
Internet Use and Export Upgrading: Firm‐level Evidence from China

Xianhai Huang,Xueyin Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/roie.12407

IF: 1.234

2019-01-01

Review of International Economics

Abstract:This paper explores the impact of widespread Internet use on the product choices of exporters. Based on a highly disaggregated firm-product-level data matched from the Annual Survey of Industrial Firms and China Customs Transaction Database, our baseline empirical analysis suggests that (1) Internet use (i.e., having an official website or corporate email) affects both extensive margin and quality margin of exported products; (2) exporters using Internet propone to expand their product line of export by introducing new products (cost-reduction effect on extensive margin); (3) the average quality of exported products becomes lower after the Internet is adopted by exporters (competition effect on quality margin). Our heterogeneous analysis further shows that (1) exporters with high productivity are immune to the negative impact of Internet use on quality margin and maintain quality growth; (2) having an official website exerts larger impacts on both extensive margin and quality margin compared with only having a corporate email system. Our research sheds light on the existing literature on Internet use and firm export behaviors.
Dynamic and Static Effects of Digital Services Trading on Economic Growth of World Regions

Richard Mulenga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54536/ajebi.v2i3.2051

2023-10-27

American Journal of Economics and Business Innovation

Abstract:The study examines the effect of digital services trading on the economic growth of panel data from five (5) world regions, namely, Africa, Asia, Latin America, Europe, and the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) between 2005 and 2021. The study employs quantitative experimental methods of Panel vector autoregression (PVAR) models as dynamic estimators and the Fixed Effects (FE) models as static estimators. The PVAR model analyses indicate that the digital services trade has a significant positive long-run effect on Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth in all five regions. For every 1% increase in digital services trade, GDP in the OECD region increases by 6.75%, followed by Europe at 3.19%, 2.11% in Latin America, 1.02% in Asia, and is lowest in the African region panel at 0.82%. The static FE analyses also shows similar results. These findings confirm the hypothesis that deep internet/digital penetration positively impacts the efficiency of digital services trade. The study, therefore, recommends that policymakers from developing world regions should increase investments in digital deepening infrastructure which should include among others, promoting, policy and regulatory measures that augment digital infrastructure installations in rural places, developing the digital skills to mitigate digital illiteracy, and promoting the adoption of cutting-edge digital technologies.
How does Digitalization Affect Trade in Goods and Services? Evidence from G20 Countries

Zi Hui Yin,Chang Hwan Choi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13132-024-02029-1

IF: 1.815

2024-06-10

Journal of the Knowledge Economy

Abstract:This study analyzes the impact of digitalization on the trade of goods and services in a gravity model. By using panel data of the Group of Twenty (G20) countries for 2005–2019, we find that (1) digitalization has a more positive effect on trade in services than on trade in goods; (2) digitalization is more likely to have a positive impact on exports, especially service exports rather than imports; (3) digitalization in high-income countries tends to have a positive effect on trade in services rather than trade in goods, whereas the use of mobile phones in middle-income countries has a promotion effect on the export of services. To promote trade volumes, G20 countries should increase investment in the development of digital technologies and reduce barriers to digital trade.

economics
Information and communications technology (ICT) and services trade

Hiranya K. Nath,Lirong Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.infoecopol.2017.06.003

IF: 2.769

2017-12-01

Information Economics and Policy

Abstract:Using panel data for 49 countries from 2000 to 2013, this paper empirically examines the impacts of ICT development on exports, imports, and total trade of ten service items. Unlike most previous studies, seven different ICT variables are used to construct a comprehensive ICT development index (IDI) that captures the access, use, and skill aspects of the technology. The results indicate that ICT development has significant positive contributions to the growth of international trade in seven (of ten) service items. For two of these – financial and other business services – both exports and imports are significantly impacted by ICT. It also has significant positive effects only on exports of transportation services and only on imports of insurance services, royalty and license fees, telecommunication services, and travel. Five of these services are ICT-enabled: this technology plays an important role in the production and delivery of these services. When we consider total (exports plus imports) trade, ICT has significant positive effects on six of the items, including financial services, insurance services, other business services, royalty and license fees, transportation and travel. Among the three aspects, ICT use is found to be more important than access and skills for trade in a number of services. These results provide interesting policy insights for ICT development and growth of services trade.

economics
Trade, policy, and economic development in the digital economy

Peter R. Herman,Sarah Oliver

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdeveco.2023.103135

2023-06-21

Journal of Development of Economics

Abstract:This paper assess the impact of internet connectivity and digital trade policies on trade and welfare. Using new measures of internet connectivity, we find a significant positive relationship between internet use and bandwidth capacity, and trade. The positive relationship between internet use and trade is present for international and domestic trade, goods and services, high- and low-income exporters, and at the intensive and extensive margin. We also find that digital trade facilitation provisions in trade agreements have significantly increased trade for high-income exporters, especially for services trade. Informed by these findings, we use a general equilibrium model of trade to assess the trade and welfare impacts of increased internet connectivity and digital trade policies for developing countries. Increasing internet connectivity can have large positive welfare impacts on poorly connected countries, but these results also highlight the dangers of developing countries falling behind if they are not able to improve internet infrastructure. Introducing digital trade provisions into an existing trade agreement between high- and low-income countries can facilitate growth in trade in services for both members.
The Effect of the Digital Economy on Services Exports Competitiveness and Ternary Margins

Hao Li,Jian Han,Yayun Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.telpol.2023.102596

IF: 4.497

2023-01-01

Telecommunications Policy

Abstract:In the era of the digital economy, improving the level of information and communications technology (ICT) development is an important measure for achieving the high-quality development of the services exports. This study constructs a comprehensive development index for the digital economy based on the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development Statistics Database (UCTADstat) to calculate the services exports competitiveness of 75 countries (regions) around the world from 2010 to 2019 and conducts ternary margin decomposition. The study empirically verifies that the digital economy promotes the competitiveness of services exports, not only driving intensive growth of quantity margin and price margin but also enhances the expansion growth of category margin. Heterogeneity analysis reveals that the effect of the digital economy on improving low- and middle-income countries' services exports competitiveness and industries with low ICT intensity is more significant than that of high-income countries and high ICT-intensity industries. The impact of the digital economy on the ternary margin of countries’ different income levels and ICT-intensity sample groups exhibits differentiated estimation results. The conclusions of this study provide novel explanations regarding the effects of the digital economy in improving services exports competitiveness and new perspectives and evidence for strategic policymaking.
Does the service trade network impact on technological complexity of exports?——New perspective based on social network approach

Li Lin,Xiaqing Lan,Xiaotian Xu,Lu Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/16081625.2024.2425842

2024-11-13

Asia-Pacific Journal of Accounting & Economics

Abstract:In the context of the digital economy, digital service trade has gradually become a new driving force for the high-quality development of foreign trade in various countries. Based on the bilateral data of digital service trade between 56 countries from 2005 to 2021, this paper constructs the global digital service trade network through social network analysis method. Also, this study examines the impact of the network characteristics on its export technology complexity. According to our research findings, first, in terms of the overall characteristics, the number of participating countries in digital service trade is increasing, and the density is overall low but showing an upward trend. Second, in terms of individual characteristics, the ranking is relatively stable, developed countries such as Europe and the United States with higher centrality, connectedness and heterogeneity are the dominant players in the digital service trade. But the indicators of each characteristic are decreasing over time, verifying the fact that the global digital service trade has become more open and inclusive. Third, we examined that centrality, connectedness, and heterogeneity all contribute significantly to export technological complexity. Technological innovation is the main path of action. The results still hold after performing a series of robustness tests.

economics,business, finance
Digital service trade and carbon total factor productivity: empirical evidence from cross-country panel data

Liu, Yi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-024-05749-1

IF: 4.08

2024-12-05

Environment Development and Sustainability

Abstract:Digital service trade (DST) occupies an increasingly important position in international trade. Moreover, it has a significant impact on the low-carbon development of the global economy. This study investigates the effect of DST on carbon total factor productivity (CTFP) and empirically examines its impact using panel data from 64 countries from 2005 to 2020. The results reveal that DST significantly promotes CTFP. Moreover, DST can improve CTFP through technological progress and industrial structure upgrading. Results of heterogeneity analysis show that digital service imports and exports significantly increase CTFP. Furthermore, DST has a positive effect on CTFP in both developed and developing economies, though the impact in developing economies is greater. Additionally, trade in financial services; charges for the use of intellectual property; telecommunications, computer, and information services; and other business services have a significant positive impact on CTFP, while significant effects were not observed for trade in insurance and pension services, as well as personal, cultural and recreational services. Based on our findings, we suggest corresponding policy implications.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology
Is the Internet bringing down language‐based barriers to international trade?

Erick Kitenge,Sajal Lahiri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/roie.12576

IF: 1.234

2021-09-21

Review of International Economics

Abstract:This paper investigates the interaction between Internet access and language similarities in international trade. We apply recent developments in gravity analysis to bilateral export data from about 205 countries over the period 1954–2014. We find a positive impact of both the Internet and language similarities, but a negative interaction between them in international trade. Our results reveal that the language elasticity of trade is lower when more people have access to the Internet and that the impact of the Internet is lower when the trading partners use similar languages. Our results also pass a number of robustness checks.

economics
The Effects of Digital Services Trade Barriers on ICT Services Exports

Jinwu Gao,Lin Yuan,Huijie Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/s1752890924500089

2024-04-26

Journal of Uncertain Systems

Abstract:The trade subjects of digital services have constructed and strictly implemented a more targeted system of trade barriers. Information Communications Technology (ICT) services, as an important trade subject in the digital services field, are more prominently affected by the digital services trade barriers. To investigate the trade effects of digital services trade barriers on ICT services exports, this paper conducts a series of empirical tests using trade panel data of 18 exporting countries and 38 importing countries during the period of 2014–2020. Our results in the benchmark regression show that digital services trade barriers significantly inhibit the expansion of ICT services exports. By the industry and country heterogeneity analysis, we first find computer services are most significantly affected by the negative effect of the digital services trade barriers; then it reveals that the degree of trade inhibition of high ICT countries exporting to low ICT countries is extremely significant, followed by low ICT inter-country exports.
Development and Influencing Factors of International Trade in Digitally Deliverable Services

Yuna Di,Ruixin Zhi,Huaixi Song,Lu Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.908420

IF: 3.8

2022-05-24

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:Introduction International trade in digitally deliverable services has been developing rapidly in recent years, especially during pandemics. However, the growth rate and scale differ among regions and countries. To promote the growth and bridge the divide of global trade in digitally deliverable services, we provide feasible policy suggestions in this paper. Methods Based on panel data of 33 countries' digitally deliverable service trade from 2005 to 2020, this study analyzes the development trends and influencing factors of international trade in digital-global service trade. Results The development of digitally deliverable services in developed countries is far ahead, while in emerging economies such as China and India, it is growing at a high speed. Digital infrastructure; human capital; and science, technology, and innovation capacity have a significant impact on the digitally deliverable trade of countries with the level of STI playing the most important influence. Further, heterogeneity analysis shows that human capital and STI capacity are more sensitive to the digitally deliverable trade of middle-income countries than to the impact of high-income countries, and the contribution of population in middle-income countries is more pronounced. Conclusion As the proportion of digital trade in global trade continues to increase, the role of digital service trade in countries' sustainable development is becoming more prominent. To cope with such opportunities and challenges, countries, especially developing countries, should actively increase digital infrastructure construction, improve talent training, vigorously develop digital technology, and enhance their innovation capacity.

psychology, multidisciplinary
International Trade in Online Services

Georgios Alaveras,Bertin Martens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2670614

2015-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper presents an innovative database of domestic and bilateral online services trade between 39 countries, including the US, the EU and some emerging market economies. It combines monetized and “free” online services in a single measure based on the volume of page views on websites of online service providers. We find that the online services market is geographically very fragmented. Less than 1% of all online service providers export worldwide and account for almost half of worldwide online services trade; they are mostly US-based. In the EU and other regions the share of online services imported from the US is very substantial. Conversely, in the US 32% of its online services providers export and these exports account for nearly twice as much as domestic demand. Application of the well-known gravity model of trade shows that trade frictions from geographical distance are greatly reduced in online services. However, cultural and linguistic borders are reinforced and home bias is stronger online than offline. We explain this paradox in terms of online information cost reduction and consumers’ quest to explore the longer tail of online supply, both at home and worldwide. Larger firms export to more markets than smaller firms. It is easier for larger online firms to reduce distance and language related trade costs; however large firms do not reduce strong online home bias. Trade costs and home bias vary considerably across services sectors though, in principle, all online services are fully tradable. The export performance of online firms is driven mostly by the comparative advantages of their home country, more so than by their own competitiveness. We conclude with some suggestions for further research.
ICT use and trade facilitation: impacts on bilateral trade of Sub-Saharan countries

Margarita Billon,Ernesto Rodriguez-Crespo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25115/eea.v38i2.3238

2020-05-21

Studies of Applied Economics

Abstract:This paper studies the impact of internet, mobile phones and broadband use on bilateral trade flows of 33 sub-Saharan countries over the period 2004-2014. We use a gravity model in which in addition to standard variables we investigate the joint impact of ICT use and trade facilitation on intra-trade flows. We find positive and significant effects for mobile phone subscriptions for the exporting country; positive impacts of broadband for both the exporting and importing countries and positive influence of internet use for the importing country. We also find a negative impact of trade facilitation on bilateral trade and an inverse relationship between ICT use and trade facilitation suggesting that the lack of trade facilitation might be hindering the potential benefits of ICT use in intra-Sub-Saharan African trade.
Equalization or polarization? The effect of the Internet on National Urban Hierarchies across the world, 2000–2018

Yu Wang,Zhou Yu,Bindong Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2022.103989

IF: 6.7

2022-10-08

Cities

Abstract:As Internet adoption and diffusion continues worldwide, little is known about its effects on the restructuring of national urban hierarchies globally. We create a city population panel data with uniform definitions within each of the 133 countries from 2000 to 2018 to study the effect of the Internet on national urban hierarchies and to examine the channels through which the effects take place. Results show that the Internet led to the equalization of urban hierarchies in the early stage and then the polarization. Initially, the Internet helped reduce communication costs, partially replaced transportation, and weakened the agglomeration of enterprises and individuals in large cities, thereby flattening national urban hierarchies. Later, the Internet mainly enhanced the production efficiency and accelerated the shift from manufacturing to services in large cities, thus increasing the large cities' attractiveness and ultimately polarizing the urban hierarchy. Our finding demonstrates that national urban hierarchies are not static and their evolution reflects not only the trade-off between economies of scale and congestion, but increasingly by the Internet—a powerful communication tool. If the trend persists, larger cities will grow at a faster pace than smaller cities and potentially increase regional inequality in countries that have extensively adopted the Internet.

urban studies
The effects of digital trade policies on digital trade

Jeongmeen Suh,Jaeyoun Roh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/twec.13407

2023-03-28

The World Economy

Abstract:As digital trade expands worldwide, the importance of policy factors in digital trade is garnering attention. However, the effectiveness of digital trade‐related policies on digital trade flow is empirically underinvestigated because of challenging data requirements. To overcome this, we combine recently developed, but separately used digital trade‐related datasets to empirically test how digital trade policies affect digital trade flows. In particular, we examine the effects of digital trade policies from two dimensions: unilateral domestic regulations and bilateral trade agreements. Our results reveal that a pair of countries experiences an increase in digital trade flow when they have a trade agreement containing digital trade‐related provisions. This tendency is even stronger when digital trade agreements contain more specific rules. On the contrary, domestic regulations recognised as digital trade barriers actually inhibit digital trade flows, and their negative effect is greater when the regulations are implemented by the importing country than the exporting one. Decomposing the barriers into several areas of regulations, we examine which area is more crucial than the others. These results may seem rather obvious, but conversely, they confirm the validity of our approach to measure digital trade flows across countries and the relevance of the digital trade policy variables.

economics,international relations,business, finance
Internet linkage and international trade: From the perspective of risk alleviation

Jie Duan,Zengxi Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/twec.13600

IF: 2

2024-05-29

World Economy

Abstract:Extensive research has studied the effect of the Internet on trade, yet little is known about its role in trade facilitation through risk alleviation. This research investigates how Internet linkage facilitates exports, particularly through the novel channel of risk alleviation. Theoretically, this paper introduces a gravity model augmented with export risk to establish the stimulating effect of Internet linkage on exports. Empirically, this paper uses inter‐domain hyperlinks as a proxy for Internet linkage in 2009, uncovering a statistically significant positive impact of Internet linkage on exports. Notably, there is a 27.8% increase in exports in reaction to a doubling of the Internet linkage intensity. By employing various techniques, we meticulously address potential endogeneity issues and substantiate the risk‐alleviation mechanism at both the country and product levels. Particularly, we find that exports to riskier countries and of riskier products benefit more from the Internet linkage. This study sheds new light on the novel channel through which the Internet promotes exports, enriching the existing literature in this field.

economics,international relations,business, finance

The effect of the Internet on service trade

Does the Development of the Internet Improve the Allocative Efficiency of Production Factors? Evidence from Surveys of Chinese Manufacturing Firms

A Study on the Effect of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) on Trade in Services in the United States

Impact of Digital Service Trade Barriers and Cross-Border Digital Service Inputs on Economic Growth

The Effect of Online Search on International Trade

Internet Use and Export Upgrading: Firm‐level Evidence from China

Dynamic and Static Effects of Digital Services Trading on Economic Growth of World Regions

How does Digitalization Affect Trade in Goods and Services? Evidence from G20 Countries

Information and communications technology (ICT) and services trade

Trade, policy, and economic development in the digital economy

The Effect of the Digital Economy on Services Exports Competitiveness and Ternary Margins

Does the service trade network impact on technological complexity of exports?——New perspective based on social network approach

Digital service trade and carbon total factor productivity: empirical evidence from cross-country panel data

Is the Internet bringing down language‐based barriers to international trade?

The Effects of Digital Services Trade Barriers on ICT Services Exports

Development and Influencing Factors of International Trade in Digitally Deliverable Services

International Trade in Online Services

ICT use and trade facilitation: impacts on bilateral trade of Sub-Saharan countries

Equalization or polarization? The effect of the Internet on National Urban Hierarchies across the world, 2000–2018

The effects of digital trade policies on digital trade

Internet linkage and international trade: From the perspective of risk alleviation