Identification and prioritization of risks for new entrants in automobile sector using Monte Carlo based approach

Sarmad Farooq,Afshan Naseem,Yasir Ahmad,Muhammad Awais Akbar,Mehran Ullah

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-62803-8

IF: 4.6

2024-06-01

Scientific Reports

Abstract:The automotive industry serves as a crucial support system for the economies of industrialized nations in their pursuit of international market competitiveness. Despite this industry's importance, most developing countries face the challenge of acquiring a reasonable economic position at the global level in the automotive sector for various reasons. The most salient reasons include inconsistent government policies, multiple taxes, investor insecurity, political instability, and currency devaluation. Identifying risks is crucial for a new entrant in the already-established automotive industry. The researchers have used multiple (qualitative and quantitative) techniques to identify and prioritize risks in setting up manufacturing plants. The efforts to tackle these identified risks are undertaken at the domestic and government levels to smoothen the establishment of industry. The risks are first identified, in the current study, by reviewing the previous literature and conducting interviews of the various stakeholders (automotive dealers, managers, and customers). Then this study uses Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) approach and develops a risk exposure (high, medium, or low) matrix for the automotive industry of Pakistan. The findings reveal that the depreciation of local currency against the foreign exchange, oligopoly nature of competition, and low market acceptability of new entrants due to their products' image are the most critical risks the automobile industry faces. These findings will help automotive research institutes in developing national policies that specifically aim to support new players in the automotive industry, particularly in addressing high-priority hazards. The results may also provide valuable insights for new participants seeking to identify and address the key challenges in the Pakistani automotive industry before entering it.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to identify and prioritize the risks faced by new entrants in Pakistan's automotive industry. Specifically, through a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods, the research aims to:

1. **Identify risks**: Through literature review and semi - structured interviews with industry - related stakeholders, determine various risks that new entrants may encounter in Pakistan's automotive industry.
2. **Evaluate risks**: Use the Monte Carlo Simulation (MCS) method to evaluate the probability and impact of these risks, and then calculate the risk exposure value of each risk.
3. **Prioritize**: Classify risks into three levels of high, medium, and low according to the risk exposure value, to help new entrants better understand and deal with these risks.

### Research background
Although Pakistan's automotive industry has experienced ups and downs in the past few decades, it has generally performed poorly due to ineffective policies and the neglect of policymakers. New market participants face multiple challenges when entering this market, including currency devaluation, oligopolistic competition, and low brand loyalty. Therefore, identifying and prioritizing these risks is crucial for new entrants to develop effective risk - management strategies.

### Research methods
1. **Qualitative research**: Through semi - structured interviews, collect information on potential risks from industry experts.
2. **Quantitative research**: Design a questionnaire based on a 5 - point Likert scale, and let 30 industry experts score the identified risks to evaluate their probability and impact.
3. **Monte Carlo simulation**: Use @Risk software for simulation, calculate the risk exposure value of each risk, and classify it into three risk exposure areas of high, medium, and low.

### Main findings
The research found that the most significant risks faced by new entrants in Pakistan's automotive industry include:
- **Currency devaluation**: The devaluation of the local currency against foreign currencies.
- **Oligopolistic competition**: A competitive environment dominated by a few companies in the market.
- **Poor new product image**: The products of new entrants have low acceptance in the market and a poor brand image.

### Conclusion
These findings are helpful for automotive research institutions to formulate national policies to support new entrants, especially for high - priority risks. At the same time, these results also provide valuable references for new participants, helping them identify and deal with key challenges before entering Pakistan's automotive market.