Abstract:Large grazers often have positive effects on the health of floristically diverse European saltmarshes. Yet, in eastern US saltmarshes dominated by a single plant species, disturbance from large grazers results in decreased ecosystem function and resilience. Thus, frameworks attempting to predict or explain large grazers' impacts must account for geographic variation in ecosystem structure. Large grazers modify vegetated ecosystems and are increasingly viewed as keystone species in trophic rewilding schemes. Yet, as their ecosystem influences are context‐dependent, a crucial challenge is identifying where grazers sustain, versus undermine, important ecosystem properties and their resilience. Previous work in diverse European saltmarshes found that, despite changing plant and invertebrate community structure, grazers do not suppress below‐ground properties, including soil organic carbon (SOC). We hypothesised that, in contrast, eastern US saltmarshes would be sensitive to large grazers as extensive areas are dominated by a single grass, Spartina alterniflora. We predicted that grazers would reduce above‐ and below‐ground Spartina biomass, suppress invertebrate densities, shift soil texture and ultimately reduce SOC concentration. We tested our hypotheses using a replicated 51‐month large grazer (horse) exclusion experiment in Georgia, coupled with observations of 14 long‐term grazed sites, spanning ~1000 km of the eastern US coast. Grazer exclusion quickly led to increased Spartina height, cover and flowering, and increased snail density. Changes in vegetation structure were reflected in modified soil texture (reduced sand, increased clay) and elevated root biomass, yet we found no response of SOC. Large grazer exclusion also reduced drought‐associated vegetation die‐off. We also observed vegetation shifts in sites along the eastern US seaboard where grazing has occurred for hundreds of years. Unlike in the exclusion experiment, long‐term grazing was associated with reduced SOC. A structural equation model implicated grazing by revealing reduced stem height as a key driver of reduced soil organic carbon. Synthesis: These results illustrate the context dependency of large grazer impacts on ecosystem properties in coastal wetlands. In contrast to well‐studied European marshes, eastern US marshes are dominated and structured by a single foundational grass species resulting in vegetation and soil properties being more sensitive to grazing. Coastal systems characterised by a single foundation species might be inherently vulnerable to large grazers and lack resilience in the face of other disturbances, underlining that frameworks to explain and predict large grazer impacts must account for geographic variation in ecosystem structure.

High δ15N and δ13C Values in Aurochs, Cattle and Sheep Bones from Salt Marshes in the North of The Netherlands

Mangrove Leaf Species-Specific Isotopic Signatures along a Salinity and Phosphorus Soil Fertility Gradients in a Subtropical Estuary

Carbon sequestration is not inhibited by livestock grazing in Danish salt marshes

Above- to Belowground Vegetation Biomass Ratio in Temperate North-East Atlantic Saltmarshes Increases Strongly with Soil Nitrogen Gradient

Ontogenetic δ15N Trends and Multidecadal Variability in Shells of the Bivalve Mollusk, Arctica islandica

Variation in stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope compositions along antlers of Qamanirjuaq caribou (Rangifer tarandus groenlandicus)

High δ15N values in Predynastic Egyptian archeological remains: A potential indicator for localised soil fertilisation practices in extreme conditions

Comparing the impact of a grazing regime with European bison versus one with free-ranging cattle on coastal dune vegetation in the Netherlands

A cross-regional examination of camelid herding practices in Peru from 900 BCE to 1450 CE: Insights from stable isotopes in camelid bone collagen and fiber

Tissue-specific carbon isotope patterns of amino acids in southern sea otters

Future climate conditions alter biomass of salt marsh plants in the Wadden Sea

Spatial ecology of moose in Sweden: Combined Sr-O-C isotope analyses of bone and antler

Carbon and Nitrogen Stable Isotope Analyses of Mammal Bone Fossils from the Zhongba Site in the Three Gorges Reservoir Region of the Yangtze River, China

Exogenous nitrogen from riverine exports promotes soil methane production in saltmarshes in China

Influence of the Keystone Grazer, Sesarma reticulatum, on the Hydrology and Organic Matter Cycling in Salt Marshes of the Southeastern USA

Region‐specific drivers cause low organic carbon stocks and sequestration rates in the saltmarsh soils of southern Scandinavia

Large grazers suppress a foundational plant and reduce soil carbon concentration in eastern US saltmarshes

Impacts of increasing levels of salt on intake, digestion, and rumen fermentation with beef cattle consuming low-quality forages

Environmental conditions in the Massif Central during the Upper Palaeolithic using stable isotope tracking (13C, 15N) of bone collagen from large herbivores

Cattle and Sheep Raising and Millet Growing in the Longshan Age in Central China: Stable Isotope Investigation at the Xinzhai Site

Top-down control of carbon sequestration: grazing affects microbial structure and function in salt marsh soils